Jedi Dooku vs TCW Maul

Started by Kurk2 pages

Jedi Dooku vs TCW Maul

Sabers, Force, All out

Takes place in death star hanger.

Round 2: SoD Maul.

Dooku fanboys, UNITE!

Maul wins.

We know nothing of Jedi Dooku now with the tossing aside of the EU amirite?

Well it's defintlly hard to say. But we still have canon accolades to go off of. He did beat Windu in blade to blade sparring, Dooku still has the force edge since he was the as stated by Yoda most learned student in the ways of the force and the blade in the orders 25,000 year history, and he's younger so his physicals are better.

Overall while Dooku still wins its lower than what he would have won if this were Darth Tyranus.

Dooku-7/10 on both.

Is any of that shit canon though?

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Is any of that shit canon though?

The part where Yoda calls Dooku the Temple's greatest student is still canon. Confirmed in Absolutely Everything You Need to Know.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
The part where Yoda calls Dooku the Temple's greatest student is still canon. Confirmed in Absolutely Everything You Need to Know.
Cool. I just want canon facts.

Dooku stomps Maul any day of the week and twice on Sundays.

Yeaaaaaaaaaaa... No.

Maul, Dooku doesn't really have any advantages at this stage in anything.

I'd probably side Maul at this point as well.

Maul, probably 6-7/10. There's not that big of a difference between Jedi Dooku and Darth Tyranus.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
The part where Yoda calls Dooku the Temple's greatest student is still canon. Confirmed in Absolutely Everything You Need to Know.

Isn't him beating Mace canon now or is that now legends.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Maul, probably 6-7/10. There's not that big of a difference between Jedi Dooku and Darth Tyranus.
If Dooku had nothing to gain why would he waste his time going to the dark side?

Originally posted by juggernaut74
If Dooku had nothing to gain why would he waste his time going to the dark side?

I said there wasn't much of a difference, not that there was none. That's why Maul takes 6-7/10 against Jedi Dooku but only 3-5/10 against Darth Tyranus in my opinion.

I'm aware there's sources outright stating that he grew more powerful and increased in ability upon joining the Sith, despite the fact that he initially joined Palpatine for political reasons as opposed to wanting power.

Originally posted by SunRazer
I said there wasn't much of a difference, not that there was none. That's why Maul takes 6-7/10 against Jedi Dooku but only 3-5/10 against Darth Tyranus in my opinion.

I'm aware there's sources outright stating that he grew more powerful and increased in ability upon joining the Sith, despite the fact that he initially joined Palpatine for political reasons as opposed to wanting power.

He's the only canon darksider that has shown the ability to use force lightning to my knowledge(Other than Sidous). I've read that's an advanced Sith technique.

But as for the fight there really isn't anything to go by regarding Jedi Dooku.

So Maul wins by default I supoose.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Isn't him beating Mace canon now or is that now legends.

That's not canon for now.

Dooku may be more powerful as a Sith Lord, but I'm not entirely sure if he's superior to his Jedi self as combatant. Jedi Dooku would be younger, perhaps stronger, stronger and with superior stamina. At this point he's already master and instructor of TK and Yoda's Order's greatest student.

Dooku should take this 6-8/10

Originally posted by Darth Thor
That's not canon for now.

Darn. I guess that means or infers that he could have bested him at one point being the orders best student.

Originally posted by McP
Dooku may be more powerful as a Sith Lord, but I'm not entirely sure if he's superior to his Jedi self as combatant. Jedi Dooku would be younger, perhaps stronger, stronger and with superior stamina. At this point he's already master and instructor of TK and Yoda's Order's greatest student.

Dooku should take this 6-8/10

He's been confirmed as improving as a Sith Lord, and even if he did have better physical attributes, which is dubious to begin with, that's not the kind of edge he needs against Maul; his physicals will always be inferior. As a Jedi he has no dueling or Force skill feats/hype to surpass Maul, so while he is a bit of an unknown I'm not ready to give him any kind of majority unless someone makes a great case for it.

Also, lol at a potential 7+/10. Sith Dooku doesn't even warrant that amount.