ROTS Vader (no suit) vs. CW Maul

Sabers
Force
All out

Maul wins.

Vader wins. Quanchi is trolling as usual.

Originally posted by Kurk
Vader wins. Quanchi is trolling as usual.

Vader takes sabers

Force is debatable to me since Vader as of ROTS was only able to stalemate Obi wan who is about equal to maul. I'm going with even.

All out goes to Vader.

Both are warriors so this would eventually fall down to skills with the blade, and Anakin is supeior in this category.

Originally posted by Kurk
Vader wins. Quanchi is trolling as usual.

As always.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
As always.

Vader wins. Maul's not overpowering him with the Force and his fighting style really doesn't match up as well as Obi-Wan's to the circumstances Obi-Wan was in when he won.

And Maul doesn't know Vader's style like a Obi Wan does.

Yep Obi-Wan taught Anakin. So a fight between those 2 is obviously going to be very different than if they didn't know each other at all. Plus Kenobi is a very defensive fighter.

So anyone saying Maul can beat Anakin just because Kenobi beat him is simply fooling themselves.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
And Maul doesn't know Vader's style like a Obi Wan does.

Quan lowballing Anakin like he does Superman.

Originally posted by playa1258
Quan lowballing Anakin like he does Superman.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I do not ignore facts. You do. Maul wins. Pre suit Vader was an emotional nutcase. Maul managed to rattle Kenobi in battle.

Originally posted by Kurk
Really? You say Anakin was an emotional nutcase yet you forget Maul was in serious physiological distress when found and continued to be after his transformation, letting his hate for Kenobi cloud his judgement. Give me a break.

Vader trashes. Maul isn't even in the same league if this is Knightfall Anakin.

Retard alert

Originally posted by ILS
Retard alert

In the opinion of the people who made Revenge of the Sith Anakin is a Level 9 Duelist. Do you know what happened the last time Maul faced a Level 9 Duelist? He got trashed. Even with Savage he'd probably lose.

Equating Vader to Sidious using a rough tiering system is pretty funny bro. Actually try making an argument for Vader thrashing Maul instead of blindly assuming it's what everyone else will go with. As far as I'm concerned he'd take a solid win, similar to his win over Dooku but more difficult due to Maul dwarfing the physical strength of aforementioned old man, but not a Cin Drallig-esque thrashing. If Savage was there he'd probably die.

Originally posted by ILS
Equating Vader to Sidious using a rough tiering system is pretty funny bro. Actually try making an argument for Vader thrashing Maul instead of blindly assuming it's what everyone else will go with. As far as I'm concerned he'd take a solid win, similar to his win over Dooku but more difficult due to Maul dwarfing the physical strength of aforementioned old man, but not a Cin Drallig-esque thrashing. If Savage was there he'd probably die.

Vader is closer to Sidious than to Kenobi. And if we use the ROTS novel, Mace and the narrative flat out state that Anakin rivals Yoda. You can ignore the facts if you want bro.