This is actually an interesting fight. I'd give it to the first team. Caedus is almost on the level of Luke as a duelist, and given how Dooku fell against Anakin and how he seems to be terrified of Palpatine, I think it's safe to say that the gap between him and Dooku is greater than the gap between Anakin and Maul.
Of course, maybe "Zonakin" exists and he dispatches Maul in like 15 seconds, but even then I'd give Caedus a respectable shot at soloing. I contend that the Dooku-tier is really far below the Sidious-tier, which Caedus seems to be hovering around (this is necessary given a chain of powerscaling from Dooku -> Anakin -> Obi Wan -> Oppress compared to Sidious vs. Oppress, for example, and to keep Sidious > Vitiate).