Was Rey's force progression WAY too fast?

Started by Darth Abonis3 pages

Was Rey's force progression WAY too fast?

I think Rey learned how to use the Force too fast. It took Luke 3 years to really start being able to do telekinesis and his first ligthsaber duel with Vader in the comics was a joke. Yet, Rey is able to do a mind trick on her second try; Luke couldn't do it at all in Heir to the Jedi. Also, Rey was able to beat Kylo Ren in a lightsaber duel, without any training and summoned Luke's old lightsaber to her hand, by defying the force pull of Kylo, a highly trained Force-sensitive. What I'm saying is. Is this just a glaring plot problem or is Rey perhaps the strongest in the Force in Disney canon, and the fastest learner; above Luke, Ezra, Kanan etc.

One thing, she didn’t really overpower Kylo in a force pull. Kylo, for whatever reason, was incapable of pulling Anakin’s saber to himself. Rey was.

But yes, her progression was too fast for my liking. Hopefully, we get a reason for this in the next film.

Lightsabers give visions now and choose their wielders like wands from Harry Potter.

If I'm cool with that (and I am), I can handle Rey learning the Force real goods real fasts.

It's magic. She's a wizard.

I don't mind Rey as long as she dies in the next film and her powers in the Force are never explained.

Originally posted by Bentley
I don't mind Rey as long as she dies in the next film and her powers in the Force are never explained.

Lol

I'm hoping that Luke gives her the Potara earrings so she can fuse with Kylo Ren to defeat Snoke.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
I'm hoping that Luke gives her the Potara earrings so she can fuse with Kylo Ren to defeat Snoke.

LOL.

As long as that will give us more wizard lightsaber 'unts unts unts unts' scenes... with extra CGI, I'm fine with that.

Originally posted by Darth Abonis
I think Rey learned how to use the Force too fast. It took Luke 3 years to really start being able to do telekinesis and his first ligthsaber duel with Vader in the comics was a joke. Yet, Rey is able to do a mind trick on her second try; Luke couldn't do it at all in Heir to the Jedi. Also, Rey was able to beat Kylo Ren in a lightsaber duel, without any training and summoned Luke's old lightsaber to her hand, by defying the force pull of Kylo, a highly trained Force-sensitive. What I'm saying is. Is this just a glaring plot problem or is Rey perhaps the strongest in the Force in Disney canon, and the fastest learner; above Luke, Ezra, Kanan etc.

What you're not taking into account is Rey most likely being an extremely powerful Force user who was trained from a very young age before being left on Jakku with a mental block. The events of The Force Awakens kickstarting her brain and awakening what she already knew.

Originally posted by NewLanceWindu
What you're not taking into account is Rey most likely being an extremely powerful Force user who was trained from a very young age before being left on Jakku with a mental block. The events of The Force Awakens kickstarting her brain and awakening what she already knew.

Hopefully.

Originally posted by NewLanceWindu
What you're not taking into account is Rey most likely being an extremely powerful Force user who was trained from a very young age before being left on Jakku with a mental block. The events of The Force Awakens kickstarting her brain and awakening what she already knew.

Assumptions, assumptions...

Originally posted by queeq
Assumptions, assumptions...

Absolutely, but is the most likely theory.

I dunno. There's very little evidence of that. I'm waiting fro the next movie. 😉

If Rey doesn't turn out to be Palpatine in drag I'll be disappointed.

Ah, well me too! 😉

If the "lightsabers give visions" idea came from Lucas, it would be about as panned as midi-chilorians.

The Force gives visions... not lightsabers.

Not really. She got first-hand experience with mind techniques, Kylo practically projecting stuff into her head, then it took her multiple tries to get it right.

Note Luke was deflecting blaster bolts in a few minutes after starting.

What do mind techniques have to do with Force visions? Besides Kylo uses the Force to extract stuff from people like Rey and Poe.

Originally posted by Q99
Not really. She got first-hand experience with mind techniques, Kylo practically projecting stuff into her head, then it took her multiple tries to get it right.

Note Luke was deflecting blaster bolts in a few minutes after starting.

Sure, but that is merely him letting the force guide him not actively using force powers.

Which is something Rey was capable of doing this before she had any force training as we see when she flies the Falcon.