DCnU Captain Atom Vs Blue Marvel

Started by Zack M2 pages

DCnU Captain Atom Vs Blue Marvel

vs

Battle of the Adams, eh?
Fine i'll bite, see if i can kick start this for you with some patented unpopular opinions.
In a real world sense, both are fairly recent characters, debuting between 08-11. Both are physically powerful energy manipulators who can do some amazing things and were hyped to the point that they became very polarizing;
readers either thought they were pretty cool, and became fans, or saw them as threats to the pecking order for more established characters and became haters.

In-universe, BM has the experience edge, and is the smarter of the two. While overall power is arguable (their power sources are vastly different, and can be used in different ways than just fly blast punch), i think those two factors give BM the win more often than not.

BM CAN just overload Atom to the point he explodes...

Originally posted by riv6672
Battle of the Adams, eh?
Fine i'll bite, see if i can kick start this for you with some patented unpopular opinions.
In a real world sense, both are fairly recent characters, debuting between 08-11. Both are physically powerful energy manipulators who can do some amazing things and were hyped to the point that they became very polarizing;
readers either thought they were pretty cool, and became fans, or saw them as threats to the pecking order for more established characters and became haters.

In-universe, BM has the experience edge, and is the smarter of the two. While overall power is arguable (their power sources are vastly different, and can be used in different ways than just fly blast punch), i think those two factors give BM the win more often than not.

Cap has the speed edge and could possibly ko him like Mogul.

Atom stomps IMO, different levels of power all together.

Originally posted by Zack M
Cap has the speed edge and could possibly ko him like Mogul.

Of course he could.

My thinking BM wins the majority doesnt mean i'm going to deny what CA has in his arsenal.

Captain Atom waves his hand, and Blue Marvel is in the after life 2 seconds later

Captain Atom shitstomps.

As usual, the low herald Blue Marvel is overrated.

Next up, Blue Marvel Vs Howard The Duck. Phil makes exact same post. 😆

Atom stomps and Blue Marvel is high Herald.

Atom.

Originally posted by carver9
Atom stomps and Blue Marvel is high Herald.

Not for a majority, and, Superman level.

Are you saying that Atom doesn't beat BM for a majority?

If so, what's your rationale?

I gave it already, guy.
I'm the only one who HAS given any kind of rationale (at length). Check the first response, where i said i'd try and kick start the thread with my patented unpopular opinions. 😛

I thought you were joking there, guy.

Atom stomps. 👆

You thought wrong, guy.
About me joking AND Atom stomping. This match isnt a stomp no matter who you think wins.

You should have presented something in that Pre DoS Superman v Blue Marvel thread, Riv.
We could see where he stacks up to probably the weakest canonical Superman since the golden age.

Must have missed that one.

Originally posted by riv6672
Not for a majority, and, Superman level.

He really does. A sweep. Do you know of Atom fts?

Sure do; researched him several months ago.