Byrne era Superman vs savage Hulk.

Started by lawest92 pages
lawest9 Senior Member

Byrne era Superman vs savage Hulk.

Fight takes place in downtown metropolis, all powers allowed and no bfr.
To the death or by KO. who wins and why?

carver9 Senior Member

You make more Hulk threads than... and when someone vote for him you question them.

Savage Hulk wins.

Delta1938 True King of House of El

Originally posted by carver9
You make more Hulk threads than... and when someone vote for him you question them.

Savage Hulk wins.

Carter--

Originally posted by carver9

Naah, on average, Hulk shakes planets during his fights. No Herald has done this on more occasions than Hulk has. Not one. Hulk is the master of shaking earth during his fights.
Originally posted by Delta1938
Give me 500 examples of Hulk shaking planets during his fight or concede to being a liar.
lawest9 Senior Member

Originally posted by carver9
You make more Hulk threads than... and when someone vote for him you question them.

Savage Hulk wins.

Since when do I make so many Hulk tbreads?

lawest9 Senior Member

🎃🎃🎃🎃🎈🎃💝💝💝💝💝🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔫🔦🔦🔦🔦🔦🔦

quanchi112 Disney

Hulk wins.

Surtur Restricted

So I guess Byrne era Superman lacked any notable super speed if he can be defeated by Savage Hulk.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
So I guess Byrne era Superman lacked any notable super speed if he can be defeated by Savage Hulk.
In character. 😉

Surtur Restricted

The OP also says all powers allowed, to me that sounds like he's going to actually use the powers he has.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
The OP also says all powers allowed, to me that sounds like he's going to actually use the powers he has.
What about in character don't you get ?

Surtur Restricted

It just seems weird to me if "all powers" are specified and then you come in and say "yeah he won't use his speed because it's in character".

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
It just seems weird to me if "all powers" are specified and then you come in and say "yeah he won't use his speed because it's in character".
He can use his speed just not in the manner you're suggesting. This isn't power set debating.

Surtur Restricted

Okay so in what manner can he use his speed in this fight according to you? Give me an example of something Superman is allowed to do with his speed. Besides fly fast.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
Okay so in what manner can he use his speed in this fight according to you? Give me an example of something Superman is allowed to do with his speed. Besides fly fast.
Anything that can be supported by the comics. Same rules apply to each character. In every Thor thread do you argue a godblast ?

Surtur Restricted

I'd argue a god blast if it was against someone he had the time to set one up for, if it was needed.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
I'd argue a god blast if it was against someone he had the time to set one up for, if it was needed.
Then you aren't arguing in character since he has used this less than 1 percent of his showings. Point proven.

Surtur Restricted

If Thor has the ability to perform a god blast, which we know he does, and we put him in a fight against someone he knows he couldn't defeat without it..why wouldn't he attempt to use it? Can you give me an in character reason as to why? I will note saying "he rarely does it" isn't an in character reason.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
If Thor has the ability to perform a god blast, which we know he does, and we put him in a fight against someone he knows he couldn't defeat without it..why wouldn't he attempt to use it? Can you give me an in character reason as to why? I will note saying "he rarely does it" isn't an in character reason.
He uses this attack less than one percent of the time. You're like most Cbr posters you argue based off a few showings ignoring the majority of how the character fights. That's cbr.

Surtur Restricted

You didn't answer my question. You are using the argument of "in character". I want you to explain why in character he wouldn't use it. In a situation where Thor knows the only way to win is to use this ability, why does he think to himself "I don't think I should do this"?

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
You didn't answer my question. You are using the argument of "in character". I want you to explain why in character he wouldn't use it. In a situation where Thor knows the only way to win is to use this ability, why does he think to himself "I don't think I should do this"?
He uses it less than one percent of the time. In character means what the character is most likely to do so less than one percent doesn't mean that criteria. Any other obvious points you never further clarified. You also ran off the to catch a murderer thread.