Ahsoka Tano vs. Bastila Shan vs. Sirak

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
The Jedi Order in KotOR had half it's members abandon it and they are in the middle of a civil war. The only Jedi who saw war are with Revan/Malak. Not to mention that describes the Republic and the Jedi perfectly at pretty much any point in galactic history in Legends. And their ability to use the Force wasn't diminished, as in Legends at least, that power comes from within. Their ability to see the future was diminished and use more esoteric powers were deminished.

I'm not arguing what is (in the EU) but rather what I think it should be in the new canon.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
And in KOTOR, the notable Jedi are Revan, Meetra, Bastila, and... ?
Everyone else is kinda meh.

Like I said though, random sith can fire out lightning like it's going out of style. We aren't talking dark jedi either, just random dickish sith.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Just looked at Ant's RT and saw that Bastila knocked Revan and a couple companions over with Telekinesis on Lehon in KOTOR.

I concede Bastila's victory.

Bastila was holding back because she's in love with Revan and wasn't trying to kill him so it still counts. excellent

Bastila.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Remember though, Lehon is a powerful nexus. Feats don't count on Lehon. 🙂

Do not forget that Bastilla is a Mandalorian War veteran along with Meetra, Revan & Malak. Ahsoka never made the rank of Jedi Knight and Sirak came from Dathomir which is Nightsister territory and never completed his training.

What was it that Darth Traya said about Revan? "Looking at Revan was like staring into the heart of the Force." Back to Bastilla, she wielded a double blade and was probably trained in Juyo. Although Ahsoka uses the Jar-Kai fighting technique she would be destroyed by Bastilla.

Fighting droids is not the same as fighting fanatical Mandalorians.

No she is not. To pretty much all of that.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Even half that much telekinetic power is more impressive than what Sirak or Ahsoka can muster up.

Not really seeing outside of nexus/DS showings she really has the proves she can beat Ahsoka.

Originally posted by Darth Truculent
Sirak came from Dathomir which is Nightsister territory and never completed his training.

What was it that Darth Traya said about Revan? "Looking at Revan was like staring into the heart of the Force." Back to Bastilla, she wielded a double blade and was probably trained in Juyo.

In any case, you're statements about Sirak are frightfully inaccurate. Sirak trained on Korriban and grauated from the academy as its second greatest student. And like Bastila he also wielded the double bladed lightsaber, but is actually confirmed as knowing Juyo.

And I'm not sure what Traya's Revan wank does to prove Bastila's victory.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Meh, if she's going from getting stomped by Malak to twice contending with an altogether more powerful opponent, and the first time with backup, she's either's massively amped by Lehon and the Star Forge, or the turning to the dark side dramatically advanced her powers, or both.

Not really seeing outside of nexus/DS showings she really has the proves she can beat Ahsoka.

Originally posted by Darth Truculent
Although Ahsoka uses the Jar-Kai fighting technique she would be destroyed by Bastilla.

Fighting droids is not the same as fighting fanatical Mandalorians.

Bruh, Ahsoka has also fought Mandalorians in Pre Vizsla and the Death Watch.

Darth Maul is considered the "deadliest Sith Apprentice" - he was personally trained by Sidious. So training at Korriban at a school is a joke to me. It's "Harvard" for dark side acolytes. Bane even knew the teachings that the teachings of the Brotherhood were false when he read Revan.

The Mandalorians of the Mandalorian Wars nearly conquered the Republic. They were more organized and better equipped. Nearly forgot, they were amped up by Lord Vitiate. The savage battles of Dxun, Serrecco, Malachor V just to name some Ahsoka and Sirak would not survive. Besides didn't beat the shit out of Sirak in round 2 nearly killing him?

Originally posted by Darth Truculent
Darth Maul is considered the "deadliest Sith Apprentice" - he was personally trained by Sidious. So training at Korriban at a school is a joke to me. It's "Harvard" for dark side acolytes. Bane even knew the teachings that the teachings of the Brotherhood were false when he read Revan.

The Mandalorians of the Mandalorian Wars nearly conquered the Republic. They were more organized and better equipped. Nearly forgot, they were amped up by Lord Vitiate. The savage battles of Dxun, Serrecco, Malachor V just to name some Ahsoka and Sirak would not survive. Besides didn't beat the shit out of Sirak in round 2 nearly killing him?

And arguing anyone who survived the mandalorian wars is greater than Ahsoka or Sirak is fallacious, as that would imply random non-force sensitive mandalorian wars soldier veteran #394 is superior to Ahsoka or Sirak, which is obviously not the case.

Also Trainee Bane is a greater combatant than anyone in this thread.

Bastila is not a veteran of the Mandalorian Wars. She was a Padawan throughout the entirety of KotOR. She is not a master of Juyo, or even the saberstaff for all we know. Bringing up Revan hype doesn't really change any of this.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Well I was saying if we used her DS showings she'd be>Ahsoka. Without those showings she probably loses to Ahsoka.

None of them are going to be in a position to put substantial pressure on each other and outfence them without getting interrupted, its going to be limited to brief bouts, and considering they are all in a similar league as duelists none of them should be incapable keeping up.

What its likely to come down to is stamina instead of skill, whoever tires will be unable to keep pace, leave an opening, and get cut down.

In that respect I might give an edge for Bastila for having marginally superior Force reserves, Ahsoka and Sirak's style are also very energy intensive and designed to overwhelm their opponents quickly, which will be difficult here.

Although Sirak could prove something of a spin ball, depending on how able Bastila and Ahsoka are against Force lightning, that kind of power will seriously sap at their stamina if they are struck.