Geralt of Rivia visits the Hobbitverse
In this fight, Geralt visits the Hobbitverse and face to face with any stuff in the verse. He has all of the weapons and equipments from Witcher series and also he brought Roach as a transport to travel the verse
Could he solo the verse or will he dies in a round?
Originally posted by Nusa105
What??? i never meant like that 😕
You meant "can Geralt live in the world of Lotr like he does in Witcherverse?" If that is your question I'm inclined to say yes. Geralt will have to alter the way he lives, unlike Witcher Lotr isn't populated with monsters around every corner. But I have no doubt that he has the required ability to survive and live in almost any random fantasy world, as long as that, and only that, is his main objective.
Originally posted by Utrigita
You meant "can Geralt live in the world of Lotr like he does in Witcherverse?" If that is your question I'm inclined to say yes. Geralt will have to alter the way he lives, unlike Witcher Lotr isn't populated with monsters around every corner. But I have no doubt that he has the required ability to survive and live in almost any random fantasy world, as long as that, and only that, is his main objective.
Originally posted by CosmicComet
Yes.Sorry, the licensing house for it has deemed it so.
It's just like Star Wars did with expanded universe material (before Disney acquired them).
So fan indignation is pointless as a retort.
Please point me to a single place where they called it canon.
Or, actually point me to their general canon layout.
I'll wait.
Upon double checking, it appears to be muddied and not outright.
I was recalling this article from two years ago on hazy memory, about how they collaborated intensely with the ME Enterprises, but this is all they said:
“But in terms of the big ideas, we basically [told the licensee], ‘Here’s what we want to do with Celebrimbor, and here’s why we think it fits within the canon. … It doesn’t conflict with anything,’” said Roberts. “‘It’s not trying to tell a different version than what’s out there. It’s filling in some gaps, and sort of illuminating a part of the past that people don’t know about, or wasn’t written about. …’ And they basically said, ‘Yeah, that looks good.’”Going back and forth between the different books to maintain continuity was a “rigorous process” for Monolith’s fact-checkers, especially since Tolkien often revised his early work to make sure that some elements stayed consistent with his latest books.
“That’s part of why we have Middle-earth Enterprises, too,” said Roberts. “They’re checking on that stuff for us as well. So we have multiple sets of eyes in case one of us missed a detail or overlooked something.”
So not outright said anywhere.
Regardless, since its a different medium from the primary(novels), its secondary canon at most anyway(--so case of contradictions default to the writings--), if its even canon at all.