Supergirl vs Thor(Jane Foster)

Morals on

In character

Standard versions

Death or KO or any means

Metropolis

Who wins?

Isn't this getting a little out of hand? Foster has yet to show anything better than an over-hyped knock down. No offense, but let's see how things go next issue.

Originally posted by Stoic
Isn't this getting a little out of hand? Foster has yet to show anything better than an over-hyped knock down. No offense, but let's see how things go next issue.

Originally posted by zopzop
You see the latest scans? It's a LOT more than a mere knockdown. She's done more vs Odin than anyone short of Galactus.

It will be his worse loss.

Originally posted by zopzop
You see the latest scans? It's a LOT more than a mere knockdown. She's done more vs Odin than anyone short of Galactus.

It's the writing that's shit. Odin under the correct writer would have placed her in an eldritch containment bubble after face planting her into the dirt. Unless of course Jane Thor has more power than Thor who also inherited his mother's powers. That is and has always been one of the things that separated all of the other ersatz Thor's from the original. The writer of this story has managed to toss 50 yrs of continuity out of the window. This is honestly as bad as Loeb's Rulk.

Originally posted by Stoic
Isn't this getting a little out of hand? Foster has yet to show anything better than an over-hyped knock down. No offense, but let's see how things go next issue.

She also controls Mjolnir far better than Thor Odinson ever did.

Ripped vibranium/adamantium/whatever.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
She also controls Mjolnir far better than Thor Odinson ever did.

Ripped vibranium/adamantium/whatever.

I know. I wanted to forget the Adamantium ripping part though. I mean, you do recall Nul and what he did right? This entire thing places some pretty bad implications on more than just Odin if you follow. It's a universe wide retcon unless they steer away from this course.

Originally posted by Stoic
It's the writing that's shit. Odin under the correct writer would have placed her in an eldritch containment bubble after face planting her into the dirt. Unless of course Jane Thor has more power than Thor who also inherited his mother's powers. That is and has always been one of the things that separated all of the other ersatz Thor's from the original. The writer of this story has managed to toss 50 yrs of continuity out of the window.

Since Marvel already did a zombiverse, how about a Caitlinverse, where it can be shown, once and for all, that all politically-correct, female versions are (not equal to but) naturally more powerful than their original male counterparts.

Originally posted by Stoic
It's a universe wide retcon unless they steer away from this course.

Speed wins here. Without speed Supergirl loses.

Thor wrecks

Thor

I don't like Whor, but more so I don't like what she represents. But even I will admit that it was bad ass when she attacked Odin with Jupiters red spot storm.

Originally posted by h1a8
Speed wins here. Without speed Supergirl loses.

Thor

Originally posted by DarkOdin
well Jane's battle with Odin showed they both were battling at a rate of speed that Supergirl wouldn't even have a edge in that department

Pre-DcnU Supergirl 7/10
PC Supergirl a stomp
Current Supergirl, dunno probably 6/10
DoS Supergirl (Matrix) Jane 9/10

Doubt it, their combat speed was very impressive bouceing for Saturn to Jupiter in the time it takes to grow 2 Punch's Supergirl is not speed blitzing jane

Well, there's the fight with Barry. Though Barry was not out to hit her.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
Doubt it, their combat speed was very impressive bouceing for Saturn to Jupiter in the time it takes to grow 2 Punch's Supergirl is not speed blitzing jane

In close quarters, Jane wouldn't even know what hit her.

Originally posted by Philosophía
That's travel speed. Green Lanterns fight across planetary distances, too.

In close quarters, Jane wouldn't even know what hit her.