HoTlander vs Rebels Ahsoka

HoT. Better saber skills, better Force feats, better combat feats, etc. The Ahsoka/Vader fight was more of a negative for Vader than a positive for Ahsoka, seeing as he failed to get the holocron from Ezra and didn't demolish Ahsoka. Her showings really don't say anything about her being able to combat Vader and win. Her driving him back was impressive, yes, but her only major hit on him was done when he wasn't paying her any attention.

Originally posted by Tondemonai
The Ahsoka/Vader fight was more of a negative for Vader than a positive for Ahsoka, seeing as he failed to get the holocron from Ezra and didn't demolish Ahsoka. Her showings really don't say anything about her being able to combat Vader and win. Her driving him back was impressive, yes, but her only major hit on him was done when he wasn't paying her any attention.

Originally posted by Tondemonai
HoT. Better saber skills, better Force feats, better combat feats, etc. The Ahsoka/Vader fight was more of a negative for Vader than a positive for Ahsoka, seeing as he failed to get the holocron from Ezra and didn't demolish Ahsoka. Her showings really don't say anything about her being able to combat Vader and win. Her driving him back was impressive, yes, but her only major hit on him was done when he wasn't paying her any attention.

Hotlander.

Originally posted by Nephthys
One good fight against an opponent with conflicted feelings towards her, that she lost, doesn't trump the HoTs numerous superior feats and victories. Ahsoka struggled to defeat the Inquisitors. For all you go on about Ahsoka lasting so long against Vader, the Brother lasted about as long against her. 5th Bro for Maul tier? The Hero would own those fools.

It's a poor showing for Vader.

Anyway nice try, but Dave states explicitly that he wasn’t conflicted and was instead quite motivated in doing away with her. GG.

And well done for pointing out the obvious jobbing in Rebels. 👆

Wouldn't Vader being motivated to end her, just skew the line more of she being dead?

Granted again, ambiguous ending is ambiguous, but still.

****ing ambiguous endings..

@Beni: oh please. Don't pretend Ahsoka will be anywhere near HoTlander once he gets his destiny saber kek

Speaking the HoT, I wonder what fancy shit BW is gonna pull out when they actually decide to destroy Vitiate/Valk/whatever his name is.

One thing, are we going with the issue that the HoT is now the confirmed Outlander? Because all the trailers seem to point the HoT being the one character.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
Wouldn't Vader being motivated to end her, just skew the line more of she being dead?

Granted again, ambiguous ending is ambiguous, but still.

****ing ambiguous endings..

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
Most people don't think she's alive here, kek.

Wasn't really saying specifically to anyone here, was more general.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
@Beni: oh please. Don't pretend Ahsoka will be anywhere near HoTlander once he gets his destiny saber kek

Ahsoka will always be inferior. 🙂

Originally posted by Beniboybling
You sound threatened Neph, worried Ahsoka might be approaching one of your precious TOR characters? Bane’s next. 🙂

Anyway nice try, but Dave states explicitly that he wasn’t conflicted and was instead quite motivated in doing away with her. GG.

And well done for pointing out the obvious jobbing in Rebels. 👆

Threatened? Not at all, I'm not the one quoting carthage here. Nice attempt trying to handwave my argument off as jobbing though. Unfortunately though, you just shot yourself in the foot. If you acknowledge that jobbing is a legitimate explanation for a fight then you open yourself up to the same argument being used against you. Why can't Vader be the one jobbing? If your whole argument for Ahsoka is that she lasted long against Vader, you have to deal with the fact that the 5th Brother lasted possibly longer against her without her able to defeat him like Vader did to her.

Dave stated that Vader had conflicted emotions about her and that she reminded him of his former self. Wanting to kill her doesn't change that, he wanted to kill Dooku and Obi-Wan as well but was unbalanced by his emotions.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Threatened? Not at all, I'm not the one quoting carthage here. Nice attempt trying to handwave my argument off as jobbing though. Unfortunately though, you just shot yourself in the foot. If you acknowledge that jobbing is a legitimate explanation for a fight then you open yourself up to the same argument being used against you. Why can't Vader be the one jobbing? If your whole argument for Ahsoka is that she lasted long against Vader, you have to deal with the fact that the 5th Brother lasted possibly longer against her without her able to defeat him like Vader did to her.

1. Ahsoka has already trashed him
2. He was trashed by Maul, whom Ahsoka duelled evenly with.
3. Extending the duel served the plot i.e. giving Maul time to chat with Ezra then intervene.

What proof is there Vader was jobbing against Ahsoka And "he was conflicted" is an entirely different argument and isn't jobbing even if it where the case, o naw, it doesn't open me up to anything, hon.

Dave stated that Vader had conflicted emotions about her and that she reminded him of his former self.

Wanting to kill her doesn't change that, he wanted to kill Dooku and Obi-Wan as well but was unbalanced by his emotions.