Who can beat Bane in a lightsaber duel?

Started by The Ellimist3 pages

Actually it's a [legends] canon source that you can't dismiss because you personally dislike it. 👆

I can do that. Why because if disney can dismiss alot of EU material, than Ill dismiss there word on it. Plain and simple.

*thumbs up poop emoji's and crap*

Then why give me shit for my opinions on Bane, if it's all a matter of opinion anyway?

(btw, one of the sources was from Disney canon)

Because you dont like the character, why bother praising that fact and

The fact you used a disney canon source, to validate things...there is AN ODD fickle thing I notice. Fans cant think for themselves, some need validation from a canon source.

They are so willing to drop everything they know on the flip of a dime because a business that knows ****all about SW and where the EU came from calls it "legends/canon" for what?

So they can make stories (lies)?

Lets be frank here they arent gonna remake KOTOR, they arent gonna mess with Exar kun, Darth Traya.....why because there attention is diverted to the damn new movies or anything original trilogy related.

I can go further on the plot holes they left by just outright declaring "Legends/canon" before thinking and putting some thought into it.

So, for that why should I respect there word as law? When they didnt even read a book or comic themselves, and just place whats canon or not because **** it.

Originally posted by TheDarthBoy
Because you dont like the character, why bother praising that fact and

Ad hominem fallacy. *yawn*


The fact you used a disney canon source, to validate things...there is AN ODD fickle thing I notice. Fans cant think for themselves, some need validation from a canon source.

If we're not using canon sources, then what are we using? DarthBoy's gut feeling?


They are so willing to drop everything they know on the flip of a dime because a business that knows ****all about SW and where the EU came from calls it "legends/canon" for what?

Actually, the idea that the Banite Sith would grow stronger isn't some sort of random insert from an ignorant sourcebook author; it's integral to the philosophy of the Rule of Two, lol.


So they can make stories (lies)?

Lets be frank here they arent gonna remake KOTOR, they arent gonna mess with Exar kun, Darth Traya.....why because there attention is diverted to the damn new movies or anything original trilogy related.

I can go further on the plot holes they left by just outright declaring "Legends/canon" before thinking and putting some thought into it.

So, for that why should I respect there word as law? When they didnt even read a book or comic themselves, and just place whats canon or not because **** it.

In the Darth Bane books in question, the namesake character states outright multiple times that he wants his line's apprentices to surpass their masters. He got really nervous when he thought Zannah wasn't going to do this. Drew himself wrote that Bane wants to be surpassed. Did you even read the books? (rhetorical question: you probably did, but couldn't understand them on any level)

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Ad hominem fallacy. Im loosing my composure

If we're using canon sources, then what are we using? DarthBoy's gut feeling?

Actually, the idea that the Banite Sith would grow stronger is some sort of random insert from an ignorant sourcebook author; it's [b]integral to the philosophy of the Rule of Two, wait........

In the Darth Bane books in question, the namesake character states outright multiple times that he wants his line's apprentices to not surpass their masters. He got really brave when he thought Zannah was going to do this. Drew himself didnt write that Bane wants to be surpassed. Did you even read the books? (rhetorical question: you probably did not, but could understand them on any level) [/B]

Strongest person he can beat?

Probably Maul.

Weakest person he'd lose to?

Hmm Aurra Sing? Idk actually

Originally posted by JKBart
[b]Lightsabers only, DoE Bane can be beaten by:
- Xesh,
- Exar Kun,
- Ulic Qel-Droma,
- Revan,
- Darth Malak,
- Darth Nyriss,
- Scourge,
- Darth Malgus,
- Hero of Python,
- Wrath II,
- Darth Marr,
- Arcann,
- more TOR characters,
- Yoda,
- Mace Windu,
- Obi-Wan Kenobi,
- Anakin Skywalker,
- Plo Koon,
- Kit Fisto,
- Agen Kolar,
- Saesee Tiin,
- Palpatine,
- Plagueis,
- Tenebrous,
- Venamis,
- Darth Maul,
- Asajj Ventress,
- Savage Opress,
- General Grievous,
- Sora Bulq,
- Galen Marek,
- Luke Skywalker,
- Kyle Katarn,
- Mara Jade Skywalker,
- Saba Sebatyne,
- Corran Horn,
- Jaina Solo,
- Jacen Solo,
- Anakin Solo,
- Tresina Lobi,
- Srasuu Talon,
- Gaalan,
- Darth Krayt,
- Cade Skywalker,
- Darth Talon,
- Darth Nihl,
- Darth Wyyrlok III,
- Karness Muur. [/B]
lol @ Darth Maul beating Bane when he can't even cast or defend against lightning.

^ didn't he literally walk through a nightsister's lightning?

My dog.

Yeah, he didn't know how to properly defend against it, so he had to tank the whole thing. He was lucky it was fodder tier lightning. 👆

lol don't you just hold your lightsaber out? Does Obi Wan receive special training against it or did he figure that out?

The guy has a couple showings against lightning where in most cases he was in no position to defend against it due to circumstances, but then we get this one instance where he has no excuse, and the guy gets put on his knees and cringes. He may be caught off guard, but afterwards he still had lightsabers and surprise wasn't a factor anymore so he had no excuse, and instead of showing any effort to properly defend against, he just tanked the whole thing and cut her down. Plus, isn't there the whole "Maul was not trained to use lightning" thing?

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Strongest person he can beat?

Probably Maul.

Weakest person he'd lose to?

Hmm Aurra Sing?

Huh?

Or it could just be that the comic is 16 years old, and it's more likely that with a revised look at the character, lightning isn't as esoteric anymore and Maul can probably hold his lightsaber in front of it.

Otherwise one would need to maintain the position that AotC Kenobi, Ventress, basically everyone and their grandmother, can defend against lightning and Darth Maul, one of the most powerful and highly trained Sith in history who has personally witnessed lightning being deflected, and in cut content is seen blocking it alongside his apprentice (who has also had adequate experience being attacked by it), is pretty much the only one who can't do it. I'd estimate you're pretty retarded if that is your position, unless like Sinious you're just kidding.

Originally posted by Sinious
Yeah, he didn't know how to properly defend against it, so he had to tank the whole thing. He was lucky it was fodder tier lightning. 👆

Mighella was hardly fodder. 🙄

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Strongest person he can beat?

Probably Maul.

Weakest person he'd lose to?

Hmm Aurra Sing? Idk actually

But he has An'ya Kuro being capable of very easily matching Aurra as a duelist and An'ya's not taking Bane or Maul in a duel LOL

Such sacrilege. The idea that anyone could take Bane in a duel is just preposterous! Most unorthodox!

Such sacrilege. The idea of someone challenging your boo bear is just preposterous! Most unorthodox!

Nah, remove Bane from the chain and it still makes zero sense. An'ya>>Aurra>Maul apparently