Revan vs. Anakin Skywalker

Originally posted by The_Tempest

Even more pleasing is the fact that I'm about to watch CA:CV.

Hail Hydra, Sin.

Is Hydra still alive?

Edit: Nvm, no spoilers 🙂

Originally posted by The Ellimist

Anyway, your argument rests on the quotes that Vitiate < RotS Sidious.

You admitted as such.

You'll bring forward quotes that puts Palpatine above Vitiate.

I'll reject them for a 101 reasons, such as that they were made before Vitiate was a thing.

You'll let go on some of the quotes and grasp to others, trying to argue it still counts.

I'll argue they don't count.

And after a couple pages of going back and forth with nothing happening, one of us will stop responding.

And that will be that.

Given I have no interest to waste my time on that, I don't plan on going that course of action.

So, yeah, Revan wins. 👆

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
I was trying to explain to you why no one gives two shits what you say. 🙄

But everyone cares so much about you, Ant.

Anyway, your argument rests on the quotes that Vitiate < RotS Sidious.

That's one of my arguments. The other one is that Lucas has called Anakin the most powerful of all time, Chee says Lucas's word is G canon, and this > your opinion. 👆

I'll reject them for a 101 reasons, such as that they were made before Vitiate was a thing.

I already responded to this. You ignore it, of course, because I analyze the epistomology of authorial intent and whatnot, and it seems to pass the event horizon of understanding with you.

Given I have no interest to waste my time on that, I don't plan on going that course of action.

Because you actually think you compare with me intellectually. 👆

Good luck on those AP's though, which you apparently actually have to study for, lawl.

Your ownage is complete. Please go back to the kiddie pool.

Ant wasn't trying to argue the point with you, Ellimist. He was explaining why no one cares about your dumb argument enough to seriously rebut it. Shrieking about ad hominems just makes you look clueless.

Seeing as how somebody just expressed getting "pissed off" at my "Anakin wank", and seeing as how you and Ant have been trying for 4 pages, it seems like you care quite a deal. 👆

Neph, oh buddy, how has real life not sent your delusions of intellectual superiority crashing down on your face?

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Seeing as how somebody just expressed getting "pissed off" at my "Anakin wank", and seeing as how you and Ant have been trying for 4 pages, it seems like you care quite a deal. 👆

Yeah, I don't get it either, Ant. You argue so passionately yet you don't care as everyone's mind can't be changed? Isn't that just arguing for the sake of it then?

Since my return, I've only debated Elm, since I've yet to determine if he is unchangeable like the rest.

Remember when I raped you so hard in Revan v. Dooku that you went on a five month retirement?

Lol, old timers like Ellim are immune to your type B cancer Ant. Only my type A cancer gets through to that lot.

That made no sense. mmm

It is only your lack of understanding. You still have much to learn.

Revan > Darth Krayt.

There have been debaters who have changed my mind, directly or indirectly. Tempest, NewGuy, Lightsnake, Advent and Beni have, among others. Ant's good enough for fun but he still needs to get that pedigree...

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Since my return, I've only debated Elm, since I've yet to determine if he is unchangeable like the rest.

Remember when I raped you so hard in Revan v. Dooku that you went on a five month retirement?

Yes, which makes your long post about not caring even more weird lol.

And no, not really. I remember you harping on a powerful force push, a bunch of vague uncontrollable in game mechanics, and lots of quotes that declare him among the best of his era lol. I did agree with SKILLZ, tho, that Revan is above Dooku with the force (maybe it was in a PM that I agreed), but nowhere near Sidious, and certainly not powerful enough to one shot a Dooku level, two declarations you laughably made.

I always found a way to get through to you. 🙂

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I always found a way to get through to you. 🙂

You got them SKILLZ lil bruh.

Now I'm a simple observer. Beyond the beyond, if you will. 🙂

The ants, no pun intended, can fight over the scraps. The forum has already been won.

Ant has shit tier logic. If Lucas says he doesn't care about EU, then Chee's statement that his word is G canon stands uncontested; Lucas doesn't care about EU, so if Chee wants to just correlate his word with canon he doesn't care. Even if he says "my word doesn't relate to EU", this doesn't affect whether Chee can just coopt his. Duh.

So when Lucas says Anakin is GOAT, whether he personally cares to translate it to EU, Chee's word is what matters, so that's what it stands for. This doesn't contradict Lucas's EU apathy at all.

On phone but basically Anakin > Revan is canon > appeals to personal incredulity.