Vaylin - sabers only gauntlet

Started by JKBart1 pages

Vaylin - sabers only gauntlet

The rules
* In character
* Lightsabers/melee only
* 5 meters distance
* Throne room on Naboo is the fighting ground
* Full heal after each round

The gauntlet
1. Darth Malgus
2. Exar Kun
3. Revan
4. Obi-Wan Kenobi
5. Anakin Skywalker
6. Mace Windu
7. Darth Plagueis
8. LotF Jacen Solo
9. TPM Palpatine
10. RotS Yoda

gets stomped every round

1.

hmmm

Re: Vaylin - sabers only gauntlet

Originally posted by JKBart
[b]The rules
* In character
* Lightsabers/melee only
* 5 meters distance
* Throne room on Naboo is the fighting ground
* Full heal after each round

The gauntlet
1. Darth Malgus
2. Exar Kun
3. Revan
4. Obi-Wan Kenobi
5. Anakin Skywalker
6. Mace Windu
7. Darth Plagueis
8. LotF Jacen Solo
9. TPM Palpatine
10. RotS Yoda [/B]

1. Probably dies.
2. Dies.
3. Dies.
4. Dies.
5. Is destroyed.
6. Horribly dies.
7. Horribly dies.
8. Dies.
9. Horribly dies.
10. Is destroyed.

@ Bartlander

The placement of Malgus and Revan confuses me.

Why, tbh?

I was interested if this hole "philosophy advancement" and Eternal Empire's mental superior resulting in superior results in everything meant they also evolved beyond their predecessors like Malgus and Revan, and being direct result of evolution from them, guys like Arcann or Vaylin should hold superiority just because of being the "later versions" of teachings that came before (like RotJ Vader would defeat RotS Anakin because of absolutely perfect knowledge of everything his younger self would do, you get it).

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Why, tbh?
Cause he usually places them higher.

Originally posted by carthage
gets stomped every round

And why should we assume that Vaylin is really bad at lightsaber combat?

Because you'd be arguing in her favor, which more or less is an auto-loss. Also she lost to Senya who everyone here would godstomp

Originally posted by carthage
Because you'd be arguing in her favor, which more or less is an auto-loss. Also she lost to Senya who everyone here would godstomp

I am not in the position to determine Vaylin's place in Lightsaber combat due to limited information at hand.

However, Vaylin's loss to Senya doesn't proves that she sucks with a Lightsaber. Senya could be honed to perfection in melee-oriented combat techniques as the leader of Knights of Zakuul back in her day. Senya was also Vaylin's mother and it is hard to kill your own parent.

Its too ambiguous of a feat, and everyone here rank among the greatest duelists in the mythos. She needs more showings

We're not saying Vaylin is a bad duelist but based off showing she simply can't compete with those listed here.