Obi-Wan Kenobi vs. Shaak Ti

It was a Coalition

Originally posted by Selenial
of Darkness

**** you sas

Originally posted by Jaggarath
Shadow Guard scaling is so retarded it's honestly offensive.

Originally posted by Jaggarath

Originally posted by Selenial
it was the winter of

paine, agony, despuir.

What's retarded about Shadow Guard scaling? 🙂

🙂

ILS only likes it cause it allows him to wank Maul lol. And Ant debunked it pretty thoroughly.

Don’t disrespect ILS like that 🙂

He's just stating the facts 🙂

Originally posted by DarthCaedus77
ILS only likes it cause it allows him to wank Maul lol. And Ant debunked it pretty thoroughly.

Where did Maul fight Shadow Guards?

The scaling goes Maul > Ventress/Emperor's Hand Mara > Shadow Guard. Gotta love fact files.

I don't see how that makes Maul any more impressive.

Originally posted by Geistalt
I don't see how that makes Maul any more impressive.

A Shadow Guard fought Marek mid TFU and was stated to be "tough work". This allows Maul to scale above mid TFU Marek who has some pretty insane feats.

However it has been debunked on multiple occasions.

Didn’t we already know Maul was better than mid-game Galen?

In sabers, sure.

He did the heavy lifting in the duel against Sidious, after all.

Originally posted by BestDebaterEver
The scaling goes Maul > Ventress/Emperor's Hand Mara > Shadow Guard. Gotta love fact files.

Wasn't referring to a SG being above Maul but using his superiority over one to scale to Marek isn't viable at all, Ant debunked it.

Originally posted by DarthCaedus77
Kenobi. And scaling from Magnaguards is about as valid as the BS Shadow Guard scaling.

Agreed, kinda. Magnaguard scaling doesn't work in general because they have different skillsets. It's like scaling from generic Jedi Knights and assuming they're all equal.

Slightly different case when comparing invisible hand Magnaguards to the ones on Coruscant, since they're the same.

I always find it entertaining though that people use Shaak's performance against them to justify placing her low, when no one insinuates Kenobi's shit for almost being killed by one on the bridge of the Invisible hand mmm

it’s more of the case that people miss the forest for the trees, as usual tbh