Ben Skywalker vs. Luminara Unduli

Both are in their prime; battle takes place in the Jedi Temple.

I think Ben should take this unless shes on Bota.

It's pretty much an unknown, all depends on how you can rate her fight against Anakin, which was obviously a pretty weird setup.

Changed it to Unduli.

Why not just make a new thread?

Because I can edit it to a better matchup.

Lumirana wins in a good fight

Either way

Originally posted by JKBart
Lumirana wins in a good fight

Originally posted by carthage
Either way

I was more impressed by his feats/rapid growth in FOTJ than her losing to a pre-Prime Ventress.

then why'd u say it could go either way

Prime Ben is probably Sidious tier, lmao.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Prime Ben is probably Sidious tier, lmao.

I mean Legacy happened, so if we fill in the blanks, there's a chance he did.

Well obviously when we discuss "prime" Ben in this thread we aren't talking about a hypothetical, future version of him we've never seen.

Originally posted by |King Joker|
Well obviously when we discuss "prime" Ben in this thread we aren't talking about a hypothetical, future version of him we've never seen.

Katarn's more skilled for sure, but not to the point where its a massive gap. Ben was already stomping nexus amped Sith/beating Kel Dor weaponsmaster's with his bare hands. His opponents were much more skilled/varied than Kyle's was at the same age, given a few more years he likely would've surpassed him.

Hard to say where he maxes out at though, but given his potential as a Skywalker he's up there for sure

Ben's performances against Tribe Sith in Ascension and Apocalypse are actually quite impressive. I'd argue that he could beat Luminara - not too sure if it's for a majority, though.