Nah. KotOR II had great potential. Obsidian screwed up. SWTOR could've fixed it, but because they're not Obsidian, so they opted not to because fvck it it's not BioWare. Meetra is imho a great and interesting character.
Anyways, as for the thread:
I don't think TOR Protags should be taken into account just yet. We have to wait and see what happens in SWTOR to determine if they turn out not being "all that".
I also don't consider Revan for this. He's up there as one of the most powerful Jedi/Sith; he's quite "all that".
Meetra is one of those I'd consider for this. Also, Anakin.
Maybe Galen Marek?
The story was interesting, the plot was interesting. It was just filled with loopholes, stupid contradictions and it was incomplete.
Why? I honestly thought Marek would be this uber powerful character who'd annihilate Vader and goes up against Palpatine in a close one, but in the end he's not on Vader's level and he almost got killed by Shaak Ti.