Modern Sith vs. Ancient Sith

MODERN SITH
⊛ SoD Darth Maul
⊛ RotS Count Dooku
⊛ RotJ Darth Vader

ANCIENT SITH
⊛ Karness Muur
⊛ Ludo Kressh
⊛ Freedon Nadd

THE RULES
⊛ Fight in Valley of the Dark Lords, nexus is active like in PT era.
⊛ Starting distance - 15 meters.
⊛ In character.

I'd side team two. Dooku and Maul can't really compete.

Muur > Vader
Nadd > Dooku
Kressh < Maul

Ancient Sith win.

Ancient Sith destroy them.

Murr considered Krayt weak.

The other two are more powerful then him.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Murr considered Krayt weak.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Ancient Sith destroy them.

The other two are more powerful then him.

Nah.

And I doubt it.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
And?

Team modern, lol.

Modern Sith handily

Muur is stated to essentially be the most powerful, specifically over Krayt and Cade, and that is just the Spirit of Karness Muur, not Prime Karness Muur.

On Had Abbadon, in the Deep Core, Krayt confronted Skywalker a second time. But a third Force-user possessed powers that outshone them both. Karness Muur, an ancient Sith spirit, blasted Krayt with overpowering energy, sending him over a cliff to the rocks below.

Source: Insider #113: Profile: Darth Krayt

No real debate about him being stronger than Krayt, who is arguably > Vader himself.

Which is only true about pre Prime Krayt, and doesn't apply to Krayt as of The Legacy comics. Likewise Draining Abeloth >>>> anything Muur is capable of whether living or dead

Yet, Karness Muur was 'post-prime' if you will, not as powerful as he was in life when he helped establish the Sith Order. You can point out Krayt is pre-prime but it would be disingenous to not afford the same courtesy to Karness Muur's spirit.

Ancient Sith in a stomp.

Modern Sith are honed for a more traditional set of challenges: Melee and Telekinesis.

Ancient Sith are masters of Sith Sorcery. They also have the MVP in Karness Muur.

Ancient Sith shall prevail handily by virtue of plethora of tricks and techniques up their sleeves that may surprise Modern Sith, IMO.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
I'd side team two. Dooku and Maul can't really compete.

What?

They can in sabers, infact they'd win in sabers, clearly. In Force however I'm not seeing anything suggesting either competes with Nadd or Muur.

I'm talking about all-out. He also didn't specify Nadd or Muur, and I don't see Kressh stomping them... at all.

Kressh loses to anyone here honestly.

Probably, yeah.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Yet, Karness Muur was 'post-prime' if you will, not as powerful as he was in life when he helped establish the Sith Order. You can point out Krayt is pre-prime but it would be disingenous to not afford the same courtesy to Karness Muur's spirit.