TCW Anakin vs. RotS Obi Wan

By when in TCW would Anakin win?

S3 and beyond

^ I'd say S4 and beyond.

After the Mortis episode did it for me.

Season 4/5 I'd say.

Originally posted by Kurk
After the Mortis episode did it for me.

Actually that could be a good cut off point.

I wasnt counting S3 because of Anakin/Kenobi's fights against Ventress and Savage, but they were both pre-Mortis.

S4 Kenobi stomped S4 Anakin in hand to hand...

Anakin didn't know who he was fighting though. Remember Kenobi and Anakin know each other's moves inside out.

Remember that sane Anakin gave Dooku the fight of his life by the end of that sane story arch.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Anakin didn't know who he was fighting though. Remember Kenobi and Anakin know each other's moves inside out.

Don't see how that matter at all.

Never. Anakin was an arrogant pup who only defeated Kenobi when he actually let him kill him as a decrepit dementia riddled old man muttering some thing about the force. Whack job.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Don't see how that matter at all.

It's called Context.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
It's called Context.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
It's called Context.

Yeah, I'm sure the fact that Kenobi knew he's fighting his best friend while Anakin thought he's fighting the man who killed his best friend somehow was advantageous to Kenobi 👆

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Yeah, I'm sure the fact that Kenobi knew he's fighting his best friend while Anakin thought he's fighting the man who killed his best friend somehow was advantageous to Kenobi 👆

Have you even read the ROTS novel?

Ever read the part during the Anakin vs Kenobi fight how they looked like 2 halves of the same warrior and knew each others fighting style more intimately than lovers?

In any case Skywalker though he was fighting some book Bounty Hunter, and you're comparing that to if he knew he was fighting a Force Wielder? Really?

I suggest you stop arguing the point now.

So you mean a force user of Anakin's calibre can only win if he knows whom he's fighting? kek.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
So you mean a force user of Anakin's calibre can only win if he knows whom he's fighting? kek.

Pretty sure severely underestimating an opponent doesn't help 👆

You've also completely ignored how Kenobi and Anakin fought each other so evenly in ROTS due to knowing each other's moves inside out. Have you even read the ROTS Novel?

Like I said, I suggest you quit this argument.

So if they knew each other moves inside out that measn Anakin should've recognised Kenobi's moves, but he didn't. Which means Kenobi had to change styles and that hindered him.

Kenobi stomps even harder 👆

Spoiler:
I love how every time Kenobi does something impressive people go an extra mile just to try to invalidate it.

Dt gets more desperate by the day.

Tbh.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
S4 Kenobi stomped S4 Anakin in hand to hand...