Hulk vs Thor

The only problem with that is Thor is a warrior and has a warriors mentality.

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Both canon battles all powerful thor is unable to deal with a mild enraged hulk and saved by the plot. Nice 👆

And We are not even talking a highly enraged hulk

Now I know why..... Smh.

If Thor uses all at his disposal it's staggering the amount of ways Hulk loses here. Even if Thor isn't in kill mode.

Again read the OP.

Originally posted by beatboks

So who does win between these two Marvel power houses in a FORUM fight.
Standard Hulk no WB, WW feats for hulk. No warriors madness for Thor. Both will use all at their disposal to win.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
So when logic fails play dumb. Gotcha...
👆

Now I know why..... Smh.

If Thor uses all at his disposal it's staggering the amount of ways Hulk loses here. Even if Thor isn't in kill mode.

Again read the OP.

Yes I agree Fanfic Thor wins

Too bad canon doesn't help your argument.

Hopefully you will get it this time.

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Nah! That is just the perception of a fan

You haven't changed nothing

Canon goes to Hulk
Fanfiction goes to Thor

👆

It's not perception it's supported by "canon" as you like to say

http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/Thorowninghulk1.jpg.html

http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/Thorowninghulk2.jpg.html

Notice it say how Thor "pauses" ?? His mistake. He held back rather than press the battle. Had he not held back he could have done as he did over the next couple of pages and kept his attack on
http://s39.photobucket.com/user/marvelkris/media/Scans/Thorowninghulk4.jpg.html
http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/Thorowninghulk5.jpg.html

Or if he had driven the battle he could have done this

http://s39.photobucket.com/user/marvelkris/media/random%20comic%20feats/Thor489-07.jpg.html

There are plenty of other examples where it's calrly shown Thor doesn't drive the attack with Hulk.

You talk about canon and fanfic. The OP stated if BOTH used everything at their disposal. That flat out states it's not a "canon fight" because Thor doesn't fight that way. He holds back against everyone to fight honorably. he doesn't use energy projection or magic in a fight if his adversary can't fight that way because it would be dishonorable.

The fact is that Physically it's been shown time and again Thor and hulk are physical peers ( discounting the regurgitated incorrect argument that Hulk is stronger)

http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/WhatIf045-39a.jpg.html

Strength that "matches his own". "the battle is now NEARLY equal"
Equal enough that Thor could do this

http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/WhatIf045-40a.jpg.html

What your calling fanfic is what a FORUM FIGHT is. The OP was set to stipulate how their powers would be used and that contradicts the way Thor does in canon. Your "logic" simply doesn't apply to the stipulated conditions of the battle.

Forum fights are supposed to ignore PIS that allows a character with greater utility to loose or only match a character who matches them in some quarters and can't contend in others. They're supposed to focus on what would happen without the plot help granted by Writers trying to come up with ways to underwrite a a character.

Originally posted by beatboks
It's not perception it's supported by "canon" as you like to say

http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/Thorowninghulk1.jpg.html

http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/Thorowninghulk2.jpg.html

Notice it say how Thor "pauses" ?? His mistake. He held back rather than press the battle. Had he not held back he could have done as he did over the next couple of pages and kept his attack on
http://s39.photobucket.com/user/marvelkris/media/Scans/Thorowninghulk4.jpg.html
http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/Thorowninghulk5.jpg.html

Or if he had driven the battle he could have done this

http://s39.photobucket.com/user/marvelkris/media/random%20comic%20feats/Thor489-07.jpg.html

There are plenty of other examples where it's calrly shown Thor doesn't drive the attack with Hulk.

You talk about canon and fanfic. The OP stated if BOTH used everything at their disposal. That flat out states it's not a "canon fight" because Thor doesn't fight that way. He holds back against everyone to fight honorably. he doesn't use energy projection or magic in a fight if his adversary can't fight that way because it would be dishonorable.

The fact is that Physically it's been shown time and again Thor and hulk are physical peers ( discounting the regurgitated incorrect argument that Hulk is stronger)

http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/WhatIf045-39a.jpg.html

Strength that "matches his own". "the battle is now NEARLY equal"
Equal enough that Thor could do this

http://s38.photobucket.com/user/Soujaboy/media/Thor%20Feats/WhatIf045-40a.jpg.html

What your calling fanfic is what a FORUM FIGHT is. The OP was set to stipulate how their powers would be used and that contradicts the way Thor does in canon. Your "logic" simply doesn't apply to the stipulated conditions of the battle.

Forum fights are supposed to ignore PIS that allows a character with greater utility to loose or only match a character who matches them in some quarters and can't contend in others. They're supposed to focus on what would happen without the plot help granted by Writers trying to come up with ways to underwrite a a character.

Jesus lord Almighty

My "logic" does not apply?

Let me see, I said Fanfic Thor wins, so I guess not even that applies?

Now I have no problem with those old fights in which I said Thor look better and I gave the edge to Thor, but that was back then. Today things have changed.

Now you call PIS in favor of Hulk but you also forget a couple of things. Hulk fights controlled by Bruce who tries to restraint the Hulk, also Hulk is not a complete idiot, he does things that casually look like accidents but are premeditated accidents and also that Hulk will not stand iddle while Thor is trying to conjure something, Hulk will savagely jump in front of Thor's face and take the fight to him ah and on a PIS off fight Hulk WILL have dynamic strength unlike some of their fights. You said PIS is off in this battle but CIS is not and let's be honest Thor fights like an idiot punching first and asking questions later.

So in character he will tend to make all the mistakes he usually makes when fighting the Hulk and Hulk will tend to make all the mistakes Hulk makes when fighting Thor, so your PIS argument goes both ways.

Also nice non canon scan of a what if story. I don't count those as I don't count Hulk's dreams of breaking Mjolnirs with his hands.

I think that what is happening here is that the term FANFIC is hard to swallow when the canon fights of this two doesn't back up the fanfic argument, so we have to completely ignore canon and go with the fanfic.

I stick to my original statement

Canon goes to Hulk
Fanfic goes to Thor

And you guys pretty much are agreed that fanfic goes to Thor the only thing is that you guys don't like the term and canon doesn't back up the conclusion.

Now IF a Hulk fan will please step up to the plate. I don't have a horse on this race and it is kind of ridiculous that I am defending the Hulk, but if you guys pay me I'll switch to the gamma tards camp to defend the hulk for you guys.

You do have a horse. It's Hulk.

😬

It's ok if you do. That's what these threads are about anyway.

And canon backs the idea that Thor is almost always holding back a majority of the time, always trying to reason during battle and looking out for innocents. That's just how it is.

So is the Hulk.

Embrace the Pak Equation.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
So is the Hulk.

Embrace the Pak Equation.

Not only Pak, other writers had banner trying to restrain the Hulk always. Pater David and Kely did it too IIRC

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
You do have a horse. It's Hulk.

😬

It's ok if you do. That's what these threads are about anyway.

And canon backs the idea that Thor is almost always holding back a majority of the time, always trying to reason during battle and looking out for innocents. That's just how it is.

Or Thor 385 where he became as berserk as hulk. Or Hulk 440.

A lot of Hulk fans are as enraged as Hulk is and can't see the truth. The authors have done everything possible to show that Thor holds back, for a variety of reasons almost all the time. Thor loves earth and it's mortals and is always concerned about collateral damage, and that includes the mortal Bruce Banner. Thor is a bit of an environmentalist and should being that his birth mother is Gaea. Thor sees himself as an honorable warrior and does not takes lives unless he has to. Now the relationship between him and Hulk is not likely to change, so you anti-Thor filth can continue to beat your chests like the biased lunatics you are. Just know the "canon" truth hasn't changed either.

facepalm

You can't even spell "canon" correctly.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Except when he isn't. Like in Hulk 300,explicitly stated to not hold back.

Or Thor 385 where he became as berserk as hulk. Or Hulk 440.

In the skirmish with Ironman? facepalm The one where he wasn't trying to injury or kill him?

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
facepalm

You can't even spell "canon" correctly.

You can't come up with a rebuttal, shit eater.

Why should I bother? You're a disgrace to neanderthals.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Why should I bother? You're a disgrace to neanderthals.

And you are a registered sex offender trying to get you baby rocks off and groom victims through this forum. Who knows whose salad you are tossing in exchange to remain here.

Stop projecting.

What are you even doing here? You don't read comics, can't debate... what's the point? Trolling? Even that you can't do too well 😂

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Stop projecting.

What are you even doing here? You don't read comics, can't debate... what's the point? Trolling? Even that you can't do too well 😂

Funny, you don't even deny being a sexual deviant, not to mention delusional. A week ago you promised you'd "make me stop." How's that going for you, President of the Troll Body? 😱

Oh, and enough with me not reading comics. Two days ago I read directly from the Marvel Previews book I got when I picked up my titles like I do every Wednesday and gave a summary in the ownage thread. I guess I faked that. 😕 Anyway, I love for you to prove just one of your bullshit claims about me. As a matter of fact, since you know so much about me, what state do I live in? Wait, do I live in the United States? 😂 How many fingers am I holding up? Tell me and I'll say how many naked bodies you have in the trunk. Balls in your court.

😯 uhh...

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
Funny, you don't even deny being a sexual deviant, not to mention delusional. A week ago you promised you'd "make me stop." How's that going for you, President of the Troll Body? 😱

Oh, and enough with me not reading comics. Two days ago I read directly from the Marvel Previews book I got when I picked up my titles like I do every Wednesday and gave a summary in the ownage thread. I guess I faked that. 😕 Anyway, I love for you to prove just one of your bullshit claims about me. As a matter of fact, since you know so much about me, what state do I live in? Wait, do I live in the United States? 😂 How many fingers am I holding up? Tell me and I'll say how many naked bodies you have in the trunk. Balls in your court.

Bavsie, you already got warned quite recently. If that's not making you stop, then you'll simply get permabanned, as I told you before.

You are an African immigrant, a virgin living in Virginia, paws instead of hands, so technically you can't hold up shit haermm Previews, huh? Bet you look at the pretty pictures on cbr and nothing more.

Over 6000 posts and still you don't know the difference between "cannon" and "canon" 😂 Tell you what, I'll help. Cannon is what you get inserted in your butthole on a daily basis.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Bavsie, you already got warned quite recently. If that's not making you stop, then you'll simply get permabanned, as I told you before.

You are an African immigrant, a virgin living in Virginia, paws instead of hands, so technically you can't hold up shit haermm Previews, huh? Bet you look at the pretty pictures on cbr and nothing more.

Over 6000 posts and still you don't know the difference between "cannon" and "canon" 😂 Tell you what, I'll help. Cannon is what you get inserted in your butthole on a daily basis.

😱 😆 hysterical