Shimrra Jamaane vs Darth Plagueis

Standard morals and such apply. Combatants start 15 meters away, bout takes place in The Supreme Overlord's Throne room.

Round 1: Random encounter, no prior knowledge.

Round 2: Plagueis knows all about the Vong's "absence" from the Force.

1. Possibly Shimrra.

2. I'd still say Plagueis. Shimrra's only real feat is almost beating Luke, but that same Luke had fought through an entire army. Realistically I don't think a non-Force sensitive is going to beat Darth Plagueis in melee.

I still say Plagueis takes both but number 1 could be really close.