Darth Revan and Malek vs Darth Tyranus and Darth Maul

This is Revan as of his Sith incarnation --- ordinary Sith Malak, sans the Star Forge upgrade. Peak Dooku and Maul.

- In character; I.E. standard morals and such apply
-Random encounter
-Standard gear and such
-Combatants start 20 meters apart
-Battle takes place atop of Vader' fortress on Vjun

Malek.*

Team 2 destroys.

Revan takes Dooku probably, but I don't think non-amped Malak can best Maul.

I think it goes down to who loses first, in which I'm not sure.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Revan takes Dooku probably, but I don't think non-amped Malak can best Maul.

I think it goes down to who loses first, in which I'm not sure.

DARTH Revan?

Dooku has better force feats and saber abilities at this point.

Before the cruiser feat, I had Dooku below Darth Revan. Now, I'm not so sure.

Darth Revan is better than Nihilus. He could easily replicate that feat.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
DARTH Revan beats Dooku?

DARTH Revan?

Dooku has better force feats and saber abilities at this point.

He has greater knowledge, raw power, and accolades.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Darth Revan is better than Nihilus. He could easily replicate that feat.

Is that ever stated or is that your belief? Even if we take Meetra's word seriously, that doesn't necessarily imply to his sith incarnation.

It does because she hadn't seen Revan since the Mandalorian Wars.

Darth Revan > Mando Wars Revan > Darth Nihilus, according to the novel.

I could've sworn she said that after Revan had been Reborn. Even if it were after she saw him, she could've sensed his KotOR power - Scourge was able to detect Revan's true power through his drugs.

Also I'm pretty sure you're being facetious, but this is probably a case where it's against your interests to push the quote too far. It's sort of like how DMB actually didn't want the factpile quote to refer to PoD Bane, because otherwise it would just be too ridiculous and grounds to dismiss it out of hand.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Revan takes Dooku probably, but I don't think non-amped Malak can best Maul.

I think it goes down to who loses first, in which I'm not sure.

Team 2

Team 2.