Sabers: Maul and Malgus are near equals in terms of dueling abilities; I'd give an edge to SoD Maul especially if armed with double sabers. It's speed vs Malgus's strength. Satele vs Savage--again, speed vs strength. Satele blitzed the sith warriors, but Savage is much stronger. I'm going to lean Savage as he defeated Ventress, Koon, and Gallia, all of whom are comparable or superior to Shan.
Force: Team one clearly
All Out: Force edge gives Team one the win (maybe)
Overall the Maul brothers have much better sync energy which is an edge in itself.
Originally posted by carthage
Malgus isn't equal to Maul in skill. He's not far off but Maul has better accolades and feats