Where to rank Darth Malgus?

Started by chingchangwalla4 pages

Where to rank Darth Malgus?

...

In saber ability, I'd put him somewhere in my top ten.

Of all time?

Dooku/Bane/Mace tier.

Banes not in Mace's or Dooku's tier lmao

You're right, he might be a bit above that level but for roundings sake...

No he's substantially below them

Originally posted by Syndicate
Dooku/Bane/Mace tier.
Originally posted by carthage
No he's substantially below them

😂

Bane's obviously the most comparable figure to Malgus because of their similarities in both style and power. But that begs the question, where to rank Bane? You'll get a lot of different answers on that one depending on who you ask... So really this thread is bound to prove somewhat unhelpful. It's best to come to your own conclusions based on your interpretation of his accomplishments and how they compare to the accomplishments of others; it's not like he's lacking in material, after all.

When I first joined, people had Bane ranked... HIGH....

Like, above Mace and some shit.

Well, we've taken care of that for the most part. 👆

When did you join? Bane has been fodder tier in the minds of KMC for years now.

I arrived a few months ~ a year before the "anti-Bane" movement started. Bane certainly wasn't considered "fodder tier" until at the very least mid-2014...

EDIT: Just checked, Jman joined about 9 months after I did, so yeah--support for Bane should still have been fairly high back then. Shit really didn't hit the fan for Bane until Carthage joined, really.

Yeah, around Dooku/Mace

Originally posted by NewGuy01
I arrived a few months ~ a year before the "anti-Bane" movement started. Bane certainly wasn't considered "fodder tier" until at the very least mid-2014, though...

Emp told me it started around the time he came to the forums. *Shrug* wouldn't be surprised if that wasn't completely factual.

Originally posted by Syndicate
Emp told me it started around the time he came to the forums. *Shrug* wouldn't be surprised if that wasn't completely factual.

Actually, he's probably not wrong. Carthage and DMB joined within a couple weeks of each other IIRC, and although there was already an anti-Bane movement amiss by then, it was Carthage who really put the nail in the old baldy's coffin.

Do you really buy into all the Bane hate yourself? I mean obviously rating Bane at Caedus level is a little much...

*clears throat*

But around Obi Wan level?

You tools are really deviating from the OP

Yeh Bane cops it on here, he is genuinely powerful...