Shaak Ti vs Asajj Ventress

Started by Beniboybling2 pages
Beniboybling Worst Member

Shaak Ti vs Asajj Ventress

My opinion of Ti has dipped quite a bit of late so I'd like to see how it compares to others.

Both characters are in their primes, who wins? 馃檪

Zenwolf Senior Member

Re: Shaak Ti vs Asajj Ventress

Originally posted by Beniboybling
My opinion of Ti has dipped quite a bit of late

How's that?

Emperordmb LSDMB

I used to say Shaak, now I'm not entirely sure, but I'd give Shaak Force and Ventress sabers.

|King Joker| Your Excellency

I'll say Ventress takes sabers and all out.

Emperordmb LSDMB

Who do you think wins Beni? I mean, Ventress is no Ahsoka, but could she pull this off?

Total Warrior Dark Councilor

Originally posted by Emperordmb
I used to say Shaak, now I'm not entirely sure, but I'd give Shaak Force and Ventress sabers.
How come you changed your mind about Ti?

Emperordmb LSDMB

Originally posted by Total Warrior
How come you changed your mind about Ti?

I used to have the Force gap between them wider due to Galen Marek's force feats, but after reexamining Shaak and Marek's duel I have their power less comparable than I did before.

Beniboybling Worst Member

Looking more closely at TFU material yeah, particularly Marek just isn't nearly as great as I assumed him to be at that point.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Who do you think wins Beni? I mean, Ventress is no Ahsoka, but could she pull this off?
I agree with Joker, she can take sabers and all-out by a slim margin.

Emperordmb LSDMB

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Looking more closely at TFU material yeah, particularly Marek just isn't nearly as great as I assumed him to be at that point.

Well yeah he's pretty hard to wank as a duelist at that point and he overpowers Shaak with the Force in all three versions anyways as far as Force abilities go.

|King Joker| Your Excellency

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Looking more closely at TFU material yeah, particularly Marek just isn't nearly as great as I assumed him to be at that point.
Can you elaborate? mmm

Beniboybling Worst Member

I'll PM you tbh. Can't reveal too much to our enemies. 馃檪

|King Joker| Your Excellency

Originally posted by Beniboybling
I'll PM you tbh. Can't reveal too much to our enemies. 馃檪
Very good. 馃檪

Selenial I Choose Violence
Originally posted by Beniboybling
Looking more closely at TFU material yeah, particularly Marek just isn't nearly as great as I assumed him to be at that point.

Elaborate.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Well yeah he's pretty hard to wank as a duelist at that point and he overpowers Shaak with the Force in all three versions anyways as far as Force abilities go.

Flat out incorrect, as I've pointed out three seperate times (which you happened to never reply to). She wasn't in a telikinetic clash with him in the novel, so he hardly overpowered her given he was on the back foot the entire time. In the Graphic novel he took her off guard, and in the game he simply force pushed her (which they'd been doing to each other the entire fight) with more tactical Gaul than she had done, hence he beat her by tactics not raw force strength.

And given he has literally no quotes that state he became a stronger duelist, merely that he became more cunning and rounded/skilled as a whole, yes, he's easy to wank.

One does not become a prodigy in the space of three weeks fighting imperial guards at best, and Stormtroopers. He was as proficient fighting Shaak Ti as he was when he fought Vader.

Though I'll not bother replying whatsoever to whatever you rebut, feel free to. I'll make my main post in the Kas'im thread 馃檪

Zenwolf Senior Member
Originally posted by Selenial

One does not become a prodigy in the space of three weeks fighting imperial guards at best

He fought those guys after Ti not before, but just a small nitpick. 馃槢

Emperordmb LSDMB

If you'd rather discuss this in that thread I'll wait for your post there to discuss it, though I grow tired of hearing about you "stomping me" or boasting about a post you haven't even made yet, so please stop this petty posturing until you actually post the damn thing lol

Selenial I Choose Violence
Originally posted by Zenwolf
He fought those guys after Ti not before, but just a small nitpick. 馃槢

That's what I meant 馃槈

Fighting people like that isn't going to dramatically improve him. Shaak Ti was supposed to be his final test for a reason.

Selenial I Choose Violence
Originally posted by Emperordmb
If you'd rather discuss this in that thread I'll wait for your post there to discuss it, though I grow tired of hearing about you "stomping me" or boasting about a post you haven't even made yet, so please stop this petty posturing until you actually post the damn thing lol

So you have no reply and must form strawman arguments entirely irrelevant to the discussion at hand.

Good start, DMB 馃檪

|King Joker| Your Excellency

Selenial, when should we expect the post? 馃檪

Emperordmb LSDMB

Originally posted by Selenial
So you have no reply and must form strawman arguments entirely irrelevant to the discussion at hand.

Good start, DMB 馃檪


No I'm saying since you've told me you won't even respond to me in this thread, I'll wait to answer this argument in our debate since that's clearly where you'd rather discuss it.

Way to twist my words Sel 馃憜

Selenial I Choose Violence
Originally posted by |King Joker|
Selenial, when should we expect the post? 馃檪

I don't ****ing know, I'm too busy watching Desperate Housewives.

Some time over the weekend though, latest Monday.

Keep reminding me tho.