My Galen vs Quanchi's Maul vs ILS's Krayt vs DMB's Bane vs Ant's Revan

Started by UCanShootMyNova3 pages

Tempest, be reasonable here. Your suggesting that Force users can simply never grow tired if they so wish it. Don't you think it's far more reasonable the text is suggesting Dooku can ward away exhaustion so that he can gather himself for a final surge rather then him literally willing himself back to a prime state?

You can see a argument being made for Marek > Sidious? Really? 😂

Yes.

It's obviously not a stance the creators of TFU ever wanted to impart but it's once that can be argued with current evidence.

Mareks stamina is insane tbh. I doubt he was much impacted. He certainly didn't seem to be.

In his fight with Vader he was described as taking gasping breaths at one point.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Sel's Krayt* wins.

🙂

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
It's obviously not a stance the creators of TFU ever wanted to impart

Really? I wouldn't agree with that. In the game Marek straight up beats Sidious in a duel. It's only with the other material that we see this wasn't necessarily the case.

You almost got me.

The smile was starting to come to my face.

😛

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Yes.

It's obviously not a stance the creators of TFU ever wanted to impart but it's once that can be argued with current evidence.

I think the best interpretation is that Marek had a peak performance in his final moments, plus a pretty explicitly described Oneness-like state.

The Oneness like state occurs when he causes the explosion.

I would agree he's performing at his best at the end of the novel, yes.

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova

I would agree he's performing at his best in his final fight, yes.

Sort of like Mace Windu in RotS, or Anakin on the Invisible Hand.

Yes.

As for the topic. mmm

I don't know enough about Quanchi's Maul, but Quanchi probably doesn't think Star Wars characters are that powerful in an absolute sense, so he's likely out. If we assume that the rest of you have similar general pictures of the capabilities of Force users, your Galen is likely the closest to Palpatine tbh.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Sel's Krayt* wins.

Sel's Krayt is paying child support. He has no time for battles with 3 part time jobs.

:mmmm:

DMB's Soresu Taalon oneshots them all.

Oh yeah. He's apparently far greater then Luke. 👆

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Oh yeah. He's apparently far greater then Luke. 👆

I do buy that post-pool Taalon is at least Luke tier.

Probably.

Is it a coincidence that DMB's favs are Bane and Taalon?