Originally posted by quanchi112
Horrible list.
TFA - 6/10 - Cons: A complete rip-off of ANH with elements from RotJ being reused as well. A hard leftist political agenda was pushed. Bad acting, music was placed at inappropriate times; bad comic relief. Pros: Awesome CGI and music by George Williams.
AotC - 6.5/10 - Cons: only marginally better than TFA; CGI was cheaply done; plot had some dry spots. Pros: Great battle scenes; good music; good development of Anakin's character—his mom scene and scenes with Padme; Padme.
RotS - 8/10 - Cons: better CGI than AotC, but still could be better; many plot holes; horrible B-team vs Sidious scene Pros: Best prequel soundtrack; very moving plot; Padme; good fight-scenes and character development.
RotJ - 8/10 - Cons: quite a bit of filler content; Death Star II was a lazy idea. Pros:Good overall story; good fight scenes for the time; good space-battles. Good soundtrack.
ESB - 9.5/10 - Cons: not too many other than minute details not worth mentioning. Pros: Compelling storyline; great soundtrack; great battles, especially Hoth; good focus on side characters.
ANH - 9.5/10 - Cons: very few other than some questionable acting by Ford. Fight scenes were underwhelming but I'll dismiss it considering the time period. Pros: You can't beat the classics 🙂
Originally posted by KurkYour list sucks. The movie's you like at the top of your list are not very rewatchable.
Feel free to leave some constructive criticism.
I'll reiterate:
TPM - 5/10 - [b]Cons: boring to watch; dry plot, bad humor. Pros:Darth Maul, duel of the fates, Padme, not horrible CGI for 1999.TFA - 6/10 - Cons: A complete rip-off of ANH with elements from RotJ being reused as well. A hard leftist political agenda was pushed. Bad acting, music was placed at inappropriate times; bad comic relief. Pros: Awesome CGI and music by George Williams.
AotC - 6.5/10 - Cons: only marginally better than TFA; CGI was cheaply done; plot had some dry spots. Pros: Great battle scenes; good music; good development of Anakin's character—his mom scene and scenes with Padme; Padme.
RotS - 8/10 - Cons: better CGI than AotC, but still could be better; many plot holes; horrible B-team vs Sidious scene Pros: Best prequel soundtrack; very moving plot; Padme; good fight-scenes and character development.
RotJ - 8/10 - Cons: quite a bit of filler content; Death Star II was a lazy idea. Pros:Good overall story; good fight scenes for the time; good space-battles. Good soundtrack.
ESB - 9.5/10 - Cons: not too many other than minute details not worth mentioning. Pros: Compelling storyline; great soundtrack; great battles, especially Hoth; good focus on side characters.
ANH - 9.5/10 - Cons: very few other than some questionable acting by Ford. Fight scenes were underwhelming but I'll dismiss it considering the time period. Pros: You can't beat the classics 🙂 [/B]