Act II Barsen'thor - Inferior to Shan/Malak/Exile?

Started by darthbane773 pages

Malak most likely, but Revan did also meet the HoT briefly by this time; so the HoT is another option.

He did?

Genuinely curious

Wasn't even aware the HoT or Barsen'thor could have story significance at the same time during the flashpoint the quote appears to happen after

Was left with the impression it was either or

Originally posted by ChaosTheory123
He did?

Genuinely curious

Wasn't even aware the HoT or Barsen'thor could have story significance at the same time during the flashpoint the quote appears to happen after

Was left with the impression it was either or

The player has a conversation with Revan no matter what class you play, it's a gameplay thing; so I take it as all of the members of the strike team being present and that everything he says about them is true from his point of view.

I mean, I figure anything he has to say about them is fair game regardless given nothing about them or the plot alters whether or not they're present

However?

Does a source exist that says they're all present for the effort? If not, I can't see how you'd reliably use the quote to link together the Barsen'thor and HoT *shrugs*

Originally posted by NewGuy01
I don't suspect it will. The fact that he's one of the best Jedi Revan has ever seen doesn't preclude him from being the very best--it just implies that are others of similar calibre. It's no different from LeGenD's big to-do about Yoda being called one of the most powerful Jedi as opposed to the most powerful in some source or another.

Yes

Ingenious

The ad nauseam tactic is budding forth :hmm

Pretty soon a flow of posts incapable of formulating further rebuttals will spring forth leeching off the original ideations of NG01 👆

I'm way too bored and awake for 3 am...

Cry less please.

Being one of the best can still have you as the best. This is just another case of Ant making some stupid leaps to wank characters he likes.

Egging someone on to debate is crying :hmm

On a debate forum

I forgot where I was, I'm sorry :maybe

And you're right, but it doesn't make you exclusively the best, or even guarantee you're near the top either

In this case, its frankly you jacking an ambiguous statement to keep a pet on a perch *shrugs*

I forgive you my son.

Sure, it doesn't. It's just a decent but ultimately fairly irrelevant quote. Just like all of these "one of" ones.

I'm not jacking anything.

I feel my faith in others dwindle further upon reminder you're older than me :hmm

Nah, you're just not particularly good at connect the dots. This line of thinking isn't so much a rebuttal as it is just lazy.

Seem pretty accusatory of kiddo's motives *shrugs*

Bearing in mind poisoning the well doesn't actually harm the contents of what he's (or you in the context of actually participating in a debate) proposing.

Its a debate, follow NewGuy01's lead and actually debate. I shouldn't have needed to lightly nudge you into an actual rebuttal *shrugs*

Its almost like I'm in the modern OBD

Also, no hard feelings or whatever the **** *shrugs*

I don't believe I'm being particularly aggressive or the like, but I'm aware outside my niche ****ers seem to take shit I say way too seriously :hmm

Let's play spot the agenda.

Anyone with passing familiarity with Kiddo can win that game :maybe

Still, poisoning the well yet again holds no real bearing on his actual content or anyone's posts here *shrugs*

Stopped clock is right twice a day, that kind of shit :maybe

Originally posted by ChaosTheory123
I mean, I figure anything he has to say about them is fair game regardless given nothing about them or the plot alters whether or not they're present

However?

Does a source exist that says they're all present for the effort? If not, I can't see how you'd reliably use the quote to link together the Barsen'thor and HoT *shrugs*

There's no direct quote no, but being it's a group Flashpoint and Revan supposedly has separate conversations with each person it's safe to guess that either they were all present or that Revan had separate discussions with each (which I find unlikely.)

Originally posted by ChaosTheory123
I feel my faith in others dwindle further upon reminder you're older than me :hmm

Nah, you're just not particularly good at connect the dots. This line of thinking isn't so much a rebuttal as it is just lazy.

Seem pretty accusatory of kiddo's motives *shrugs*

Bearing in mind poisoning the well doesn't actually harm the contents of what he's (or you in the context of actually participating in a debate) proposing.

Its a debate, follow NewGuy01's lead and actually debate. I shouldn't have needed to lightly nudge you into an actual rebuttal *shrugs*

Its almost like I'm in the modern OBD

I'm not rebutting anything you've said especially, I'm rebutting Ant's original claim that Revan saying 'Thor is "one of" the best Jedi he's ever seen implies that there's greater Jedi. As we've agreed, this isn't true. I have no agenda other than that. I'm not trying to use this in any way, it's a pointless accolade for me to use. The Barsen'thor can be argued to be superior to the names Ant dropped through her own merits, feats and accomplishments, which far exceed theirs.

Hope this helps you understand! 👆

Ant, stop with these pitiful character-peddling threads.

Agreed its only acceptable if Nova can use non canon content to wank his favorites

I think it's Malak.

Originally posted by ChaosTheory123
Anyone with passing familiarity with Kiddo can win that game :maybe

Still, poisoning the well yet again holds no real bearing on his actual content or anyone's posts here *shrugs*

Stopped clock is right twice a day, that kind of shit :maybe

Sry you picked the wrong champion.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Let's play spot the agenda.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Ant, stop with these pitiful character-peddling threads.

👆