Originally posted by Insane Titan
Carver you are the worst it says Star on panel
"My spear was forged from a Sun trapped in distorted space-time. All at once, it was a life-giving new star, and also an all-consuming supernova."
That being said, it just says that the spear was forged from a sun, and the reference to "life giving" and "supernova" is to the Sun it was forged from, not the spear itself.
I'm not quite sure what you guys are having difficulty with.
Stars ARE Suns.
And vice versa.
However, not all stars are the sun of planet Earth.
They can and do vary greatly in terms of size, mass, luminosity, density, etcetera.
Here's a popular chart that illustrates the size variance, for instance:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14043693
Maybe I need to illustrate the kind of submission I'm looking for with a concrete example or few?
😕
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=12694034
Originally posted by bluewaterrider
I'm not quite sure what you guys are having difficulty with.
Stars ARE Suns.
And vice versa.However, not all stars are the sun of planet Earth.
They can and do vary greatly in terms of size, mass, luminosity, density, etcetera.
Here's a popular chart that illustrates the size variance, for instance:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14043693Maybe I need to illustrate the kind of submission I'm looking for with a concrete example or few?
😕
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=12694034
Exactly. This argument I am having is sad. Its just sad because I know dark is smarter than this.
Originally posted by Cogito
"My spear was forged from a [b]Sun trapped in distorted space-time. All at once, it was a life-giving new star, and also an all-consuming supernova."That being said, it just says that the spear was forged from a sun, and the reference to "life giving" and "supernova" is to the Sun it was forged from, not the spear itself. [/B]
Agreed.
Originally posted by Cogitoyou can't be that thick can you? You can make a small hammer out of a giant steel girder, does that mean your lifting the girder lol.
"My spear was forged from a [b]Sun trapped in distorted space-time. All at once, it was a life-giving new star, and also an all-consuming supernova."That being said, it just says that the spear was forged from a sun, and the reference to "life giving" and "supernova" is to the Sun it was forged from, not the spear itself. [/B]
She says he's been weighed down by the weight of a STAR
Hickman does the same thing here.
Hyperion states... "I am the sun".
The Beyonder states - "foolish child. I create stars".
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/2/23992/4579735-new+avengers+032-017.jpg
Same writer referencing a Sun as a star.
Clickable link version of the above:
Star size comparison chart:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14043693
Wonder Woman towing a moon. Note that the story this appears in takes pains to make it clear this is the moon from an Earth identical to ours, that it's appearance in "our" system causes double the Lunar effects of our own (mostly destructive tides and tidal waves) and that the absence of the moon from its OWN system results in a complete LACK of tides that leaves ships beached and stranded. In other words, it is reasonably "quantified" as identical in any practical sense, with the mass and weight of the "real" moon people knew back in that era.
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=12694034
Story Title: "The Mystery of the Missing Moon"
Source: Wonder Woman #73, Volume 1
Writer: Robert Kanigher
Artist: H.G. Peter
Year: 1955
Originally posted by riv6672It can be quantified to within 10% accuracy. Meaning, we can find a lower estimate of the feat. In other words, the actual feat can be quantified to be greater than or equal to the lower estimate.
Still not quantifiable.
Size doesnt equal weight. A balloon can be the size of a bowling ball.
Posters always assume that ship was 2x earth weight, and/or present it as such.
There's a lot of empty space in a ship, they arent solid mass.
Originally posted by carver9
Hulk holding up the weight of a Sun is unquantifiable.
If Hulk did lift the weight of a star then we can find a lower estimate of the feat. Meaning, what are the smallest stars?
Anyway, can you prove that Hulk lifted such weight? If so then I'll help you quantify it to a lower estimate. Meaning, the feat took AT LEAST the lower estimate to achieve.
One more thing, it's possible that the writer meant that the staff was made out of dense star material and thus weighed a lot. For example, a teaspoon of a neutron star would weigh 10 million tons. So the edge of the staff could have been between 10-50 teaspoons of dense star material. That is to say, it was hyperbole to say "weight of a star".
Regardless the feat can be quantified to a lower estimate if Hulk indeed lifted the weight.
Originally posted by Galan007
I'd say so.I have a hard time believing that Proxima is strong enough to casually throw around stellar mass with one arm.
It was activated unless you think she walks around with poison in her hands aas well and of course you would think it was hyperbole...I wonder if you thought the book with infinite pages were hyperbole (of course not).
Originally posted by h1a8
If Hulk did lift the weight of a star then we can find a lower estimate of the feat. Meaning, what are the smallest stars?Anyway, can you prove that Hulk lifted such weight? If so then I'll help you quantify it to a lower estimate. Meaning, the feat took AT LEAST the lower estimate to achieve.
One more thing, it's possible that the writer meant that the staff was made out of dense star material and thus weighed a lot. For example, a teaspoon of a neutron star would weigh 10 million tons. So the edge of the staff could have been between 10-50 teaspoons of dense star material. That is to say, it was hyperbole to say "weight of a star".
Regardless the feat can be quantified to a lower estimate if Hulk indeed lifted the weight.
What's the size of a sun that can consume everything once going Nova?
