Revan (DarthAnt66) vs Darth Vader (The Ellimist)

Started by UCanShootMyNova13 pages

Damn it Ant! I had just caught up. >_<

Yet another great rebuttal from Ant.

There were a few things I take issue with but most of it is nitpicks and will likely be addressed by Ell.

Only one major issue.

The lightsaber comparison was wonderfully executed.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Remember that the Barsen'thor has performed the following feats before or around her fight with Darth Lachris: http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/12/124590/3909280-1478979360-M6VaQ.gif and http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/12/124590/4500220-0378116447-mGRd9.gif.

I'll clarify this point if I may. Both feats take place on Taris, which is the first planet of Act I. The Barsen'thor fights Lachris at the end of Balmorra, which is the first planet in Act II. So there's over a years difference between them.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Secondly, an unnamed Jedi Knight was capable of bringing down two buildings with the Force, while in the midst of combat, without any noted difficulty. Now, note that prior to the Galactic War, Satele Shan was the foremost Jedi warrior of her time. Thus, it seems apparent that she can, likewise, display a similar, if not substantially greater feat. And now, bringing down two buildings is far more impressive than bringing down a disabled and damaged AT-ST.

A better comparison can be made here, since Malgus fought that Jedi right after losing to Satele. And he notes that he can dispose of that Jedi at his whim in a number of ways. Obviously that wasn't the case with Satele, indicating that she was far more powerful.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Being defeated in battle against Luke Skywalker in Revenge of the Jedi
😕

Neph you're not supposed to interfere here. You know how many things I've wanted to point out? Let the two hash it out.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
😕

Noice.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
😕

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MlDw3gHoSGM

Damn.

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Neph you're not supposed to interfere here. You know how many things I've wanted to point out? Let the two hash it out.

You already interjected to point out that Starkiller had blown up the Salvation and fought through clones, don't be a filthy double standard doer. All I'm doing is pointing out some stuff Ant may have missed.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MlDw3gHoSGM
I know that dear but what you may not be aware of is that the name was changed when it hit theatres. It's called this now:

👆

But I suppose you were just trying to be witty. Or something.

Originally posted by Nephthys
You already interjected to point out that Starkiller had blown up the Salvation and fought through clones, don't be a filthy double standard doer. All I'm doing is pointing out some stuff Ant may have missed.

Well, if pointing out something is kosher.

Ell, there's a snippet in the second mission to Raxus Prime where it unequivocally states Galen hurled back hundreds of droids with a single push. Also note that the first droid feat on Raxus Prime hurled them all out through a single opening and that continued pushing caused not only the droid parts but the surrounding debris in the room and hallway beyond were swept up into a hurricane and the side effects of such caused a groundquake.

On Nar Shaddaa he buckled a docking station with a single push and with a single sweep of his arm he cleared an army of storm troopers, walkers and uggernaught tanks.

For lightning energy calcs remember that in the comic scene he has to not only power the cannon's firing mechanism but overload it with his own energy. This was enough to pierce he hull of a Star Destoryer which may or may not have been shielded.

The freighter he powers in the first mission to Raxus Prime is too large for him to jump over or get around even with his augmented speed without taking hours.

Everybody, sshhhhhhhhhhut the **** up.

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Well, if pointing out something is kosher.

Ell, there's a snippet in the second mission to Raxus Prime where it unequivocally states Galen hurled back hundreds of droids With a single push. Also note that the first droid feat on Raxus Prime hurled them all out through a single opening and that continued pushing caused not only the droid parts but the surrounding debris in the room and hallway beyond were swept up into a hurricane and the side effects of such caused a groundquake.

On Nar Shaddaa he buckled a docking station with a single push and with a single sweep of his arm he cleared an army of storm troopers, walkers and uggernaught tanks.

For lightning energy calcs remember that in the comic scene he has to not only power the cannon's firing mechanism but overload it with his own energy. This was enough to pierce he hull of a Star Destoryer which may or may not have been shielded.

The freighter he powers in the first mission to Raxus Prime is too large for him to jump over or get around even with his augmented speed without taking hours.

Don't be a prick.

Originally posted by darthbane77
sshhhhhhhhhhut the **** up.

You've no idea how closely I associate this phrase with you.

But agreed. &#128077;

Originally posted by The_Tempest
You've no idea how closely I associate this phrase with you.

But agreed. &#128077;

👆

Originally posted by Nephthys
Don't be a prick.

Lets agree to let them handle the debate themselves. They're big boys.

Not seeing Neph on this list, how flagrantly biased. 🙁

In the meanwhile, can we agree that either would stomp Bane?