FE Malgus vs ROTS Obi Wan

Started by Nephthys4 pages

You mean Malgus holding back the dropship? Yeah, its a shameful error that Nova doesn't have it.

Originally posted by Nephthys
You mean Malgus holding back the dropship? Yeah, its a shameful error that Nova doesn't have it.

Yes. It is his best feat, imo.

He reached out with the Force as
Razor continued its rise, tried to take it
in his mental grasp. Its ascent slowed.
He held forth both of his arms, made
claws of his hands, and shouted with
frustration as he sought to hold back
the power of the ship’s thrusters.

He felt a tightness in his mind, the
string of his power being drawn taut,
stretching, stretching. He would not release
the ship. Its thrusters began to
whine. He held it, teeth gritted, sweat
soaking his body, his breath a dry rattle
through his respirator.

And then the string snapped and the
ship flew free, lifting clear of the roof
doors.

Thanks.
I don't think, that Malgus could lose. Force and All-Out, tbh.

Deceived Malgus wins in all, FE stomps

Edit: Deceived doesn't take sabers, I guess

I still fail to see how he wins sabers.

He's stated to be superior to a better duelist in HoT. I take back Deceived Malgus taking sabers, though, now that I think about it

When is it stated that Malgus > HoT?
Also HoT(especially pre-KotFE) > Kenobi as duelist? Nah.

Malgus does also have a good sense/precognition feat in Ord Radama, where he senses the exact location of a minefield through a tremor in the Force. Especially noteworthy is the fact that land mines are mechanical objects.

Originally posted by Tondemonai
Deceived Malgus wins in all, FE stomps

Edit: Deceived doesn't take sabers, I guess

Malgus' feats are superior to Dooku's? Which?

EDIT: I added that feat to my Malgus RT. I thought I did have it.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
When is it stated that Malgus > HoT?

Iirc, HoT notes that Malgus' saber form is immaculate, can't remember if there was more, but I'm see Neph has it laying around somewhere.

Also HoT(especially pre-KotFE) > Kenobi as duelist? Nah.

Based on what? He was stated as being the greatest duelist in the Order before act III.

Yeah, IIRC, the Hero says that Malgus form was "flawless". Doesn't mean that he is > the HoT, tho.

Based on what is the HoT > Kenobi as duelist?
Kenobi statlemating Maul/Legends Grievous/Mustafar Anakin, soarring evenly with Anakin, holding his own against Dooku, beating Ventress and Grievous and besting Opress is better than anything the HoT has done.

I'll respond to this later, it's 1:30 am. I don't have the energy.

Okay. Good...sleep?

Originally posted by Tondemonai
Iirc, HoT notes that Malgus' saber form is immaculate, can't remember if there was more, but I'm see Neph has it laying around somewhere.

Wow. As far as character opinions concerned Windu musing that Kenobi could be greater than himself shits all over HoT's opinion of Malgus 😂

Originally posted by Tondemonai
Based on what? He was stated as being the greatest duelist in the Order before act III.

Damn that's impressive. That accolade puts the HoT above such powerhouses as Satele, and, and...and who?

Meanwhile Kenobi as of TPM was almost equal to Qui-Gon who was one of the greatest Jedi duelist ever and who himself was better than Anoon who has similar accolade than HoT. And in his prime Kenobi is better than Plo who is one of the most powerful jedi ever and even Maul praised his lightsaber skills. He is better than Fisto, Agen, Saesee. All three has better accolade than the HoT. Kenobi is also better than Grievous, who is the best hand to hand jedi killer the galaxy has ever seen, and Maul, who is one of the most skilled, deadly, and highly trained sith in the history of their Order. He also shows parity of Mace and Dooku, who are the single greatest duelists up to their time, surpassed by only Yoda and Sidious.

Get back to me when HoT even begins to scrap the dirt on Kenobi's boot.

Didn't the powerhouse Neph clearly show HoT's superiority to the likes of Mace and Tyranus? TOR must be respected, Zoltan.

Malgus one-shots.

Isn't it sad that the best duelist of TOR wouldn't get in the PT Top 6?

No, it's just mostly really funny 🙂

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Wow. As far as character opinions concerned Windu musing that Kenobi could be greater than himself shits all over HoT's opinion of Malgus 😂

That isn't what Windu indicated. He was suggesting that Obi-Wan is better suited to beating GG than him. It's not the same as the HoT, Malgus comparison. The Hero is a known master of all lightsaber forms and stated that Malgus' form was flawless. That's an impressive as hell indication of skill.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Damn that's impressive. That accolade puts the HoT above such powerhouses as Satele, and, and...and who?

Tol Braga, Kellian Jarro, Corin Tok, Jaeric Kaeden, Sajar, the Barsen'thor and many others. Just because the lightsaber skills of the PT is a thousand times as explored as TOR doesn't mean they're inferior. TOR happens to have a million times as much lightsaber combat happening, the conflict far surpasses the Clone Wars in terms of length and Jedi and Sith were furiously preparing for lightsaber dueling. There's no reason to doubt their skill.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Meanwhile Kenobi as of TPM was almost equal to Qui-Gon who was one of the greatest Jedi duelist [b]ever[/b]

A worthless accolade. So he's in the top hundred? Thousand? He'd get chumped by the Hero.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
and who himself was better than Anoon who has similar accolade than HoT.

Only from his own padawan's perspective. Bondara was obviously vastly inferior to true greats.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
And in his prime Kenobi is better than Plo who is one of the most powerful jedi ever and even Maul praised his lightsaber skills.

Oh shit, Plo Koon? Definitely HoT + right there.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
He is better than Fisto, Agen, Saesee. All three has better accolade than the HoT.

No they don't. The Hero would beat the shit out of all 3 of them.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Kenobi is also better than Grievous, who is the best hand to hand jedi killer the galaxy has ever seen,

I'm pretty sure Kenobi didn't exactly fare well against Grievous in H2H. And Kenobi only beat him by fighting him enough times to figure out his weaknesses. Grievous beat his ass the other 3 or 4 times they fought.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan and Maul, who is one of the most skilled, deadly, and highly trained sith in the history of their Order.

Again with the worthless quotes. Kenobi isn't better than Maul.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
He also shows parity of Mace and Dooku, who are the single greatest duelists up to their time, surpassed by only Yoda and Sidious.

Yeah.... parity....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pI8IkWa3LQ

Thats what that is.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Get back to me when HoT even begins to scrap the dirt on Kenobi's boot.

Disgusting.