Obi Wan Kenobi (ROTS) vs Ahsoka Tank (Rebels)

Started by Rebel953 pagesPoll

Obi Wan vs Ahsoka

Obi Wan Kenobi (ROTS) vs Ahsoka Tank (Rebels)

Sabers
Force
Allout

EDIT: Ahsoka Tano (not Tank, lol)

I'd give sabers to Kenobi, barely
Force- not sure
All out- not sure

She didn't do anything Obi Wan couldn't replicate.

Kenobi, obviously.
Good fight, nonethless.

The only reason I believe she has a good chance is because of her showing against Vader

Make it Old Ben for fairness.

Originally posted by Rebel95
The only reason I believe she has a good chance is because of her showing against Vader

Nothing Obi Wan couldn't replicate. She was semi ragdolled.

Kenobi's stated to be a superior swordsman to ANH Vader.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Kenobi's stated to be a superior swordsman to ANH Vader.

Where?

Fightsaber states that Darth Vader couldn't penetrate Old Ben's lightsaber defenses.

Another work states that Darth Vader didn't become the greatest lightsaber master in the galaxy until Old Ben's death.

Considering the fact that Episode III Obi-Wan Kenobi is significantly superior to Old Ben with a blade, he's better than Darth Vader too.

Obi wan

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Another work states that Darth Vader didn't become the greatest lightsaber master in the galaxy until Old Ben's death.

0_0

SOURCE?!

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
0_0

SOURCE?!

Source dat shit bro. Don't be like those RT makers who post scans without citing the sources.

More proof that Vader > Palpatine as a Swordsmaster 😱

Originally posted by Darth Thor
More proof that Vader > Palpatine as a Swordsmaster

While I bet you're joking, I should clarify Palpatine and Yoda weren't swordmasters at this point.

Yoda didn't carry one, and there's no evidence Palpatine kept his lightsaber following TFU.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66

Impressive accolade for Ben though that doesn't place him above him.

Right, but it puts him as Vader's equal (or superior) as a technical duelist.

Refer to my point that Ben decreased significantly since Episode III Obi-Wan.

That's only if you take the quote to mean lightsaber combat as a whole rather then just technical skill. And that doesn't take into account Obi Wan having improved augmentation due to growth in the Force and thus becoming a superior lightsaber combatant in this regard ( though not necessarily on the whole ).

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
That's only if you take the quote to mean lightsaber combat as a whole rather then just technical skill. And that doesn't take into account Obi Wan having improved augmentation due to growth in the Force and thus becoming a superior lightsaber combatant in this regard ( though not necessarily on the whole ).

I assume you mean the other way around, since I suggested it meant technical skill.

That being established, Ben's greater Force abilities (which are up for debate, in any case) still had him labeled as a "shadow of his former self" compared to Obi-Wan Kenobi in regards to combat, so I disagree.