TCW Maul/Savage Opress vs. LOTS Darth Vader/Sidious

Canon versions only
*Vader and Sidious run into the Lylek caves and instead find The Zabrak bros
*Holistic interpretation of Maul with his nuclear stockpile of experience

Force sabers all out

sidious got stomped by windu, maul was able to fight mace windu for 20 seconds, obviously maul>sidious. Vader didn't beat ahsoka, ahsoka ran away from maul(not to save ezra or anything), so obviously maul>vader. As maul>vader+sidious, maul solos

TPM clone of Maul nearly beat Vader so Maul>Vader

Savage becomes bloodlusted and ragdolls Sidious

Originally posted by Kurk
TPM clone of Maul nearly beat Vader so Maul>Vader

Savage becomes bloodlusted and ragdolls Sidious

Agree. TCW Maul > TPM Maul > Clone Maul > Vader. Vader won by impaling himself (aka PIS) but he was technically defeated in the direct engagement.

Savage choked Ventress and Dooku at the same time, a duo Sidious considered to be a threat to him, so Savage can at least stalemate Sidious until Maul beats Vader and then the duo gang up on Sid.