Carver is not allowed to quantify feats because according to him reality has nothing to do with comics.
For example a car weights lets say 1 ton on rl, but on comics a car weights fluff, so you can't compare one or the other.
Also panel display outweights narration.
So DS is correct.
The feat will be quantifiable as several times the speed of light.
Originally posted by Galan007
You have a massive comprehension problem, evidently.The scan, with NO ambiguity whatsoever, states Makk's PEAK SPEED was light speed. Moreover, the scan, with NO ambiguity whatsoever, states that light speed is the "TOP POSSIBLE SPEED" in Marvel. If you tried to say that anything else was shown or implied in that comic, you'd be wrong... Or just a liar.
The Flash scene in question, however, IS quite ambiguous as to whether or not he was moving above or below light speed(which is why you and DS are debating it so vehemently.)
My point is that one scene/showing certainly isn't the end-all/be-all for ANY character -- and Flash is no exception(he's got better feats anyway.) 🙂
What I am saying is one Author isn't law. In THAT book, yes, the top speed is light speed but if another writer wrote a character going 20 times the speed of light, the previous writer have no authority over another. That's what I'm saying. A writer can do and say what they want. Example, some writers have Superman dropping instantly from k nite and some have him resisting it. Some writers have energy drain working against Hulk and some writers doesn't. I'm not going to take one showing as fact when I know things can change author to author. If that writer wants everyone in THAT book to have a top speed of 186000 mps and in another book by a different writer they contradict this, then that's when we come on KMC and debate the common, not use one Author as fact.
Do you get it now? This is the reason I said what I said about Surfer and his grandma in my post you quoted.
Originally posted by Rao Kal El
👆On a side note, what a waste of time and intellect to debate with idiots like Carver, no offense budy, but you are mentally inadequate.
That kind of talk is really not needed.
Originally posted by carver9
I'm not going to take one showing as fact when I know things can change author to author.
Except, you do that all the time.
Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Carver is not allowed to quantify feats because according to him reality has nothing to do with comics.For example a car weights lets say 1 ton on rl, but on comics a car weights fluff, so you can't compare one or the other.
Also panel display outweights narration.
So DS is correct.
The feat will be quantifiable as several times the speed of light.
Guess what I'm doing??? Debating on this topic. 🙂
Originally posted by carver9
What I am saying is one Author isn't law. In THAT book, yes, the top speed is light speed but if another writer wrote a character going 20 times the speed of light, the previous writer have no authority over another. That's what I'm saying. A writer can do and say what they want. Example, some writers have Superman dropping instantly from k nite and some have him resisting it. Some writers have energy drain working against Hulk and some writers doesn't. I'm not going to take one showing as fact when I know things can change author to author. If that writer wants everyone in THAT book to have a top speed of 186000 mps and in another book by a different writer they contradict this, then that's when we come on KMC and debate the common, not use one Author as fact.
We'll never see WBH again then. So never put him in threads.
One authors opinion means nothing, when the vast history of Hulk shows him NOT going WBH mode.
Got it.
Originally posted by carver9
Nope, I don't. I present more than one scan to back my case.
Completely off topic, but would you kindly reply to this post I made to you?
This isn't the first time I've brought it to your attention to no response.
Originally posted by Delta1938
Completely off topic, but would you kindly reply to this post I made to you?This isn't the first time I've brought it to your attention to no response.
Quoted.
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
We'll never see WBH again then. So never put him in threads.One authors opinion means nothing, when the vast history of Hulk shows him NOT going WBH mode.
Got it.
😕
But WBH exist though just like that scan of Flash going under light speed exist. SMH. I think it's early where you are at, so I'm going to let you get a breather Darksaint. Talk to you later, on another topic besides this one. SMH.
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
WBH exists....under Pak only. So as YOUR own argument attests, we don't just followONE authors opinion. Thanks.
He does exist under Pak. Inever said anything different. I wouldn't say Doc Green would go World Breaker unless I actually seen him do it. Get some rest please.
Originally posted by carver9
He does exist under Pakistan. I never said anything different. I wouldn't say Doc Green would go World Breaker unless I actually seen him do it. Get some rest please.
So youve never ever said Savage Hulk could go WBh in a thread?
Or any other Hulk? Tread careful, now. Yes or no?