bluewaterrider
Senior Member
I've heard cycles in popular culture occur roughly every 20 years.
If so, it's very appropriate the Heroes Reborn storyline of the mid 1990s finds a counterpart in the Exitar storyline of the mid teen 2000s.
Look up Uncanny Avengers, roundabout issue #18 until #22 or so.
There you'll find the celestial called Exitar taking the place of Galactus and Kang taking on the role of Dr. Doom.
With perhaps a twist or two ...
I think the answer to your question is the Avengers.
Recall how complete their defeats were in the original Secret Wars, recall how nearly complete they were in the version we saw a year or so ago.
Secret Wars circa 1985, Onslaught Saga 199x, Heroes Reborn circa 1995, Secret Wars 2015, Exitar Saga 2015 ...
These are cases where the Heroes are not only defeated, but usually perish in the struggle, and salvation actually comes from the help of a villain or villains. Original Secret Wars? Klaw and Dr.Doom. Heroes Reborn? Dr. Doom and Silver Surfer (herald of the "Big Bad" Galactus throughout most of the series, not quite the hero most people know him as now). New Secret Wars? Molecule Man. Exitar Saga? Kang, Rogue, and Death Seed Sentry.
With the possible exception of Obsidian Age and Gamemnae, I can't really think of anything DC might have that is comparable.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gamemnae
Barring the requisite beat downs Amazo periodically gives to every generation of the Justice League, I have to declare Marvel's Avengers the "winners" here, and said "winners" by far.