Senya vs Qui-Gon Jinn

Started by MythLord2 pages

I mean, feat-wise Jinn is pretty "meh", but holistically he should be up there.

Jinn contending with Maul is better than anything I've seen from Senya. He wins sabers and all-out as well.

TPM Maul > Vaylin?

Lol ok.

Vaylin doesn't have shit on Maul in sabers, lmfao.

She absolutely does. She can contend with a far greater duelist in Arcann and she's vastly more powerful than Maul is, which certainly helps.

Also losing and dying to Maul isn't the selling point you want to be going for here. Senya actually won her fights. You really don't think Senya could replicate Jinn's showing and do better?

Arcann is a far greater duelist? Based on what?

Qui-Gon lost on account of stamina; he matched Maul with respect to actual skill per End Game. And it's a double-standard to bring down Qui-Gon's feat on the basis of simply contending and not winning, and then use a feat where Vaylin contends with Arcann rather than wins.

Beating the Outlander in a less powerful incarnation.

Lol, Maul was beating Jinn and Kenobi together. I'm pretty sure that doesn't indicate Jinn=Maul. And what makes you think Senya wouldn't also beat Jinn due to his stamina?

It isn't, because I'm not talking about just Vaylin, I'm talking about Senya. Senya defeated Vaylin, indicating that she's comparable with Arcann himself based on Vaylins performance against both of them. Arcann would crush Maul.

Arcann grew stronger after that? When?

Anyway, how is Arcann beating an Outlander shortly after he left carbonite grounds to argue that he'd pummel Maul, who certainly boasts superior accolades and feats to either?

It's common to believe that when X & Y are fighting Z, Z's contending with the combined skill of X & Y. That's not how it works at all. There's plenty of scenarios where X is very close or even equal to Z alone, and yet Y's presence is still not enough to make the critical difference.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Senya defeated Vaylin, indicating that she's comparable with Arcann himself based on Vaylins performance against both of them.

😆

Originally posted by Nephthys
Arcann would crush Maul.

😂

Much like he crushed the Smuggler I'm sure. 👆

Originally posted by Nephthys
Was that supposed to have a point, or are you merely expanding upon the list of Force Users who'd flatten Jinn with the Force?
Ah yes, Jinn will be flattened by the mighty Lana Beniko much like she flattened that Zakuul Knight scrub who had her dead to rights? Lmao be serious Neph, we both know that anyone moderately strong in the Force could have substituted for either of them in performing that feat.

Well since you asked she also kills several Zakuul Knights with a Force Wave at one point. Which is above Jinn Force Pushing some droids by approximately a bazillion magnitudes.
Marvelous, I suppose that makes her sub-Hope Satele, sub-Kavar level? Still getting decimating by Maul tbfh.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Arcann grew stronger after that? When?

Anyway, how is Arcann beating an Outlander shortly after he left carbonite grounds to argue that he'd pummel Maul, who certainly boasts superior accolades and feats to either?

It's common to believe that when X & Y are fighting Z, Z's contending with the combined skill of X & Y. That's not how it works at all. There's plenty of scenarios where X is very close or even equal to Z alone, and yet Y's presence is still not enough to make the critical difference.


Battle of Asylum took place shortly after the Outlander's release? That would be Vaylin.

And my advise is not to consider an accolade based argument because the Outlander literally humbles Darth Maul in that.

Nah. Palpatine privately musing that Maul's dueling skills were nonpareil and him being "all but invincible" in combat is beyond anything the Outlander has.

Lol, Baras was stated to be almost invincible.

How'd that work out?

I guess Maul is nigh-invincible except when it comes to jobbing against padawans.

Mmm, I wonder how its possible for the Outlander to humble Maul in anything accolade related when he's been described as one of the most skilled and highly trained Sith in history. mmm

Nonetheless, I appreciate Neph's admission that Arcann's "nearly unbeatable" defence feat is bunk. 👆

Her superior aug and stamina give her the win in 1 and 3. 2 is unarguably in her favor