Unworthy Thor vs Mortal Hercules.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Shouldn't we treat those versions differently, though?

I mean, there's an Excalibur Juggy and Thunderbolts Juggy, both depowered in a similar (if not the same) way, but we don't mix their feats.

That's extremely nitpicky

No, it's not.

You're for some reason assuming that one depowerment is equal to another, which has been proven not to be a case... GREAT MANY TIMES.

Rogers w/o SSS in his bloodstream vs HA Rogers depowered in Super Soldier mini-series.

Wolverine with his HF overloaded vs Wolverine with his HF completely disabled.

Spider-Man retaining his Other upgrades, but losing his SS.

Each case is different and needs to be studied. Herc is no different. A specific "Mortal" Herc needs to be discussed here, not some compilation.

Stilts right. One version was superhuman but with no weapons. Another version was peak human but used mystical weapons...yet still lost to shaw