Melinda May vs DCEU Batman

Started by KingD192 pages

Deadshot only lost because he A)didn't know Batman's suit was bulletproof. And B)his daughter literally jumped in the way of his kill shot and begged him not to do it.

He was fighting decently against Enchantress and taking a beating from her. He's just a normal guy though so his hits didn't do anything.

As of now Batman has only beat up Fodder, gotten saved by Floyd's little girl, punched a drowning Harley, and fought Superman with his gear.

May has taken on and taken down several people with episodes worth of feats as well as superhumans.

Agreed, neither one of those encounters required much skill to pull off.

Originally posted by Silent Master
How much skill does it take to punch a woman who is stuck in a car and half drowned?

It still takes decent striking power and reflexes to dodge someone trying to knife at point blank and ko them with one punch while underwater, especially some with the skill, speed, strength and durability feats of Harley. And from the scene after he takes her out of the water you can infer that she didn't drink much, if at all, any water due to being stuck in the car.

And while I would support May winning a healthy majority, she is not having it easy, and it wouldn't be inconceivable that Bats with the suit could eke out a win either.

Given that they were both under water it's not any more impressive than dodging a knife strike above water, actually it's less impressive because she had just been in a major accident, plus his strength advantage would mean that the water would have impeded him less.

Same goes for him knocking her out, she was half drowned and had just been in a major accident. For all you know a five-year-old could have knocked her out

Originally posted by KingD19
Deadshot only lost because he A)didn't know Batman's suit was bulletproof. And B)his daughter literally jumped in the way of his kill shot and begged him not to do it.

He was fighting decently against Enchantress and taking a beating from her. He's just a normal guy though so his hits didn't do anything.

So you don't think Batman has ever fought Deadshot before and is incapable of competing with him or a non-drowning Harley?

Strange then that Harley and Joker were running from Batman, and Deadshot fantasies about beating him.

Originally posted by KingD19

As of now Batman has only beat up Fodder, gotten saved by Floyd's little girl, punched a drowning Harley, and fought Superman with his gear.

May has taken on and taken down several people with episodes worth of feats as well as superhumans.

As of now? Yeah I guess, since we only go by on screen feats. Even though it's made pretty clear this Batman has a long history with these villains. But I guess forum rules dictate on screen feats only.

Given that though, I've not seen May move with the speed, stealth and agility that Batman did in his first scene from that cop.

Batman overwhelms her...