Girder (CW series) meele fight

Started by HulkIsHulk1 pages

Girder (CW series) meele fight

Tony fights this team in a industrial parking lot Ozymandias, The Comedian, TDKR Bane, Batfleck, Red Skull, Grant Ward, Agent May, MCU DD in a melee fight. How would it go?
Here's a Girder respect thread:
https://www.reddit.com/r/respectthreads/comments/6idk5w/respect_girder_cw_flash_series/

He beats all of them. Some of them he beats with the others.

Don't think anyone here can hit hard enough to hurt him. So, he should win eventually. It would probably take some time though, given the skill level of his opponents. Even though Barry is faster, he was a shit fighter the first time they tussled. And he had literally just regained his abilities the second time, so he probably had some rust.

Wait, what am I saying? Clearly Bane solos. 😛

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
Even though Barry is faster, he was a shit fighter the first time they tussled.

Until by the end of S3, Barry was always a shit fighter imo

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller

Wait, what am I saying? Clearly Bane solos. 😛

did H1 bite you? Take the cure immediately! 😄

On a side note, Eobard went CQC Arrow fresh off from League training while depowered and even got a bit of advantage with that metal pipe before getting spun around and pinned. That makes Barry losing to him even more understandable. Reverse Flash is not only faster, but also leagues above in skill.

Do they get standard weaponry?

Originally posted by FrothByte
Do they get standard weaponry?

Yes, but they can only use it as melee weapons

Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
Yes, but they can only use it as melee weapons

Yeah then I don't see how they can injure him enough to knock him out. Ozy and Red Skull might match him in strength for a bit but unless they have something pretty solid they can hit with (like Cap's shield for example) I don't see how they can take him out without PIS.

Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
Until by the end of S3, Barry was always a shit fighter imo

Well, Barry seems to have gotten some H2H training, at least in recent times, considering he wrecked two of the ARGUS security guys in the space of a few seconds while masquerading as Lyla, when he and Snart pulled that heist.

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
Well, Barry seems to have gotten some H2H training, at least in recent times, considering he wrecked two of the ARGUS security guys in the space of a few seconds while masquerading as Lyla, when he and Snart pulled that heist.

Yeah, his fighting skills improved from nearing the end of S2(coincidentally around the time Girder came back), but his combat decisions were still not so spectacular.
And there is one thing to support Woodward here. He was weakened and mentally impaired but still gave Barry, who had got a couple or more amps trouble

Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
Yeah, his fighting skills improved from nearing the end of S2(coincidentally around the time Girder came back), but his combat decisions were still not so spectacular.

Well, I think that's mostly for the sake of the plot. I mean we have seen Barry blitz non-speedsters countless times by now. But whenever he fights a villain of the week, instead of just blitzing them before they even know what is happening, he stops right in front of them and wastes time making wise-ass remarks, giving them plenty of time to use their powers against him. It's basically that he has gotten so fast that they can't realistically beat him normally, so they have to make Barry act like a dumbass for the episodes to be longer than like 5 minutes each.

And then there are countless instances of turning his back towards villains without knocking them out.
Then during the fights with Solovar and Grodd, he blitzed them in the same side which they were holding their shield. Anyone with half a brain would try to attack the opposite, exposed side.