Originally posted by AncientPower
Not even Revan redeemed changes this, anything short of SOR Revan is losing to Kun. Not to mention that Ulic vs Malak is really only ending one way.
It's not the cleanest measurement of two combatants, but the d20 SW guidebooks have Kun and KOTOR Revan as very very close in ability, with Kun inching out on DPS thanks to his saber. Even in terms of Force knowledge and ability they were close.
SOR Revan is an entirely different animal, and I think he would make Kun work for it. Malak, on the other hand, needed Star Forge amplification to be a contender, and while he's not a weakling, Ulic is a legendary lightsaber duelist, and I think in the end he would win.