5 DoE Banes run a gauntlet

Started by UCanShootMyNova4 pages
Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Not that I would rule out the possibility of Bane > Caedus, anyway.

DMB? Is that you? How did you get control of DC's account?

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
I doubt it. Luke didn't even one-shot Lumiya.

reverse scaling...

Originally posted by Azronger
Or maybe that's just good for Lumiya then? Lol.

Lumiya's personally admitted to being weak in the Force.

Honestly Plagueis had a good chance of blitzing or straight up overwhelming them.

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
DMB? Is that you? How did you get control of DC's account?
DC gave him his password as he put Marka above Plagueis, and Naga above Krayt.

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
DMB? Is that you? How did you get control of DC's account?

Caedus hasn't actually done anything that puts him above Bane, honestly. As an overall combatant he's handily above Bane, but from a pure power standpoint, nah.

Urs, unsurprisingly, you and Wollf failed to make a compelling case for why Ragnos > Plagueis is a preposterous stance.

Plagueis>Ragnos, or any Sith Lord for that matter is a fact. OK? Yes, it's a fact. The blurb is canon as per Leland Chee. I have shown you this quote.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Lumiya's personally admitted to being weak in the Force.

'd love to see the actual context of the statement

Per Leeland Chee, blurbs can be subjective, a statement he maid, specifically when asked about the Plagueis quote, so they aren't, as you call them, "facts".

I already went over this in another thread, where you, unsurprising to anyone one, failed to actually respond.

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Caedus hasn't actually done anything that puts him above Bane, honestly. As an overall combatant he's handily above Bane, but from a pure power standpoint, nah.

Are you talking feat-wise? Because if that's the case I'd say the same applies to Bane.

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Per Leeland Chee, blurbs can be subjective, a statement he maid, specifically when asked about the Plagueis quote, so they aren't, as you call them, "facts".

Mind providing an argument as to why Plagueis would be more powerful then Valkorion politically or in some other metric rather then in regards to power in the Force?

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Mind providing an argument as to why Plagueis would be more powerful then Valkorion politically or in some other metric rather then in regards to power in the Force?

I'm not saying the quote has some other cryptic meaning, only that it's statement isn't concrete canonical fact. As Chee seem to hint to. Sure it can be truthful, but at times, they also can be wrong. Regardless, basing your entire argument on questionable sources, isn't exactly the best form of, TBH.

Not that Valkorion is a Sith, nor is he actually involved in the discussion.

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
I'm not saying the quote has some other cryptic meaning, only that it's statement isn't concrete canonical fact. As Chee seem to hint to. Sure it can be truthful, but at times, they also can be wrong. Regardless, basing your entire argument on questionable sources, isn't exactly the best form of, TBH.

Not that Valkorion is a Sith, nor is he actually involved in the discussion.

I don't personally do that but I don't think less of people who do. Quotes are quotes.

We agree on that at least.

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Caedus hasn't actually done anything that puts him above Bane, honestly. As an overall combatant he's handily above Bane, but from a pure power standpoint, nah.

From a pure power standpoint, Caedus's great grandfather was the Force, and Bane's a makeup-wearing bald dude descended from laborers.

I don't particularly think less of others that do, but using it as a get out of jail free card is lame.

Just because " X" is canonically stated to be above "Y", that doesn't mean X will auto best "Y". It ignores combative usefullness of said power, tactical ability, martial skill, so on and so forth.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
From a pure power standpoint, Caedus's great grandfather was the Force

Really sad that he has Bane level Force feats, then. 🙁

Originally posted by NewGuy01
From a pure power standpoint, Caedus's great grandfather was the Force, and Bane's a makeup-wearing bald dude descended from laborers.

true, applies to Jaina to 👆

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Are you talking feat-wise? Because if that's the case I'd say the same applies to Bane.

I mean, mind bullet-pointing Caedus' best Force feats?

If only there was someone who could... mmm

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
I mean, mind bullet-pointing Caedus' best Force feats?

Allegedly ( thanks Ant ) collapsing a cave with Force lightning and flipping over a 40 meter cruiser.