VOTE: The Power of Anakin Skywalker - Part II

It looks like AP is going to fail to provide the goods for his(?) claims a 3rd time in a row.

Shocker.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
???

Where'd you get that?

Anakin Skywalker: But I will cause so much pain.
The Father: If there is to be balance, what you have seen must be forgotten.

Originally posted by twotter
It looks like AP is going to fail to provide the goods for his(?) claims a 3rd time in a row.

Shocker.

Oh, I'm sorry Ziggy, trying to be relevant again?

^ That was referring to the part where Anakin sees the future.

The ROTS Novel might be void in many parts though because TCW came later and overwrite parts of it. For example Dooku not knowing Anakin's true saber form would be retarded now.

Didn't FotJ stated that Yoda knew about Mortis?

@AP,

1 - As Thor said, that was specifically in regards to Anakin's vision of the future. The father never erased his memory of the entire mortis arc.

2 - Even if he did erase Anakin's memory, your claim was that they all forgot the events on mortis, where is the proof for that ?

3 - At the end of the chapter, Anakin clearly remembers the events as they happened when talking to captain Rex(?)

I was under the impression he meant all of his memories with the Son.

Ahsoka forgets everything after the Daughter heals her, as far as I remember. I'm also quite sure that Kenobi mentions his mind feeling fuzzy.

Nevertheless, my point remains, Knightfall Anakin can't be more powerful than Mortakin, if his 'what-if' incarnation amped by the Son, can only defeat Yoda & Sheev in a prolonged battle. Mortakin straight up dominates the Son & the Daughter in a fashion only the Father can.

Hence Peak Anakin must be Mortakin.

The what-if is non-canon, though.

It's still considered indicative of such a hypothetical confrontation though.

Originally posted by AncientPower
I was under the impression he meant all of his memories with the Son.

Why would you get that impression? The most obvious conclusion is that he's erasing his vision of the future, so it can become reality later on.

Ahsoka forgets everything after the Daughter heals her, as far as I remember.

Define everything.

I'm also quite sure that Kenobi mentions his mind feeling fuzzy.

Oh, his mind was felling fuzzy, was it? So that clearly means he must have forgotten everything that happened to him within a 24 hour time frame. Well my stomach is felling queasy right now, clearly it must mean I suffering from Salmonella and not just reading your posts.

Nevertheless, my point remains, Knightfall Anakin can't be more powerful than Mortakin, if his 'what-if' incarnation amped by the Son, can only defeat Yoda & Sheev in a prolonged battle. Mortakin straight up dominates the Son & the Daughter in a fashion only the Father can.

Hence Peak Anakin must be Mortakin.

Explain what version (as in time period) was used for the what-if version? I never saw it.

It's posted on the last page.

Originally posted by Greysentinel365
Tale a gander

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11122/111225346/5962797-6017436404-cwus1.jpg

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11122/111225346/5962798-3605772449-cwus1.jpg

Interesting reading that again. The Son's absence from combat and from interacting with anyone seems to be consistent with Witwer's theory, that if the Son had escaped with Anakin, then they would have left as one person.

Might also suggest the Ones are not actually "physical" beings so Anakin's dominance of the Son and Daughter may not be a TK feat. Regardless it was still the most powerful display of the Force in Canon.