Luke's standing next to Vader

1) Luke suffered Gethzerion on Dathomir. So Vader being personally more powerful ins't going to make a difference to how well Luke does against her on said planet.

2) Right, but both of those are at least partially because he's the Emperors right hand man. The wording of both quotes seem to imply it's more than Force power being discussed here.

ninja'd by az

Fair enough.

Regardless, Luke is at least as powerful as Vader by ROTJ. Being less skilled in the ways of the force and wary of powers he hasn't experienced in practice, doesn't mitigate that fact his augmentation matches Vader's in combat.

Originally posted by Azronger
I remember seeing it in NewGuy's old Luke RT, which has for some reason disappeared.

I vaguely remember the quote you're referring to. Pretty sure he said "you are the greatest of the Jedi," which in context was not necessarily related to power.

Just another SW inconsistency. Perhaps Luke really was more powerful than Vader, but I doubt it. There's more evidence that puts Vader>Luke at this point in time, at least without his rage amp

Yea, it's referring to Luke when he was enraged

Originally posted by NewGuy01
I vaguely remember the quote you're referring to. Pretty sure he said "you are the greatest of the Jedi," which in context was not necessarily related to power.

I may be unaware of the context, but I do also remember Luke tanking Kar Vastor's attacks without flinching. That'd be a pretty blatant showcase of meliority to Windu if my memory serves me correct.

Originally posted by Rebel95
Just another SW inconsistency. Perhaps Luke really was more powerful than Vader, but I doubt it. There's more evidence that puts Vader>Luke at this point in time, at least without his rage amp

What do you mean?