Benjamin Kenobi (ANH) vs ROTS Obi-Wan Kenobi (ROTS)

Who wins

Originally posted by Big Gerald
Benjamin

Sabers: ROTS
Force: ANH
All out: Really not sure

ben's a superior duelist and force user.

Don't know.

ANH Kenobi.

Ben

You guys think Ben grew as a swordsman too?

A lot of people, many great people, are saying A New Hope Kenobi can't really use his lightsaber that well.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan

RotS takes sabers

ANH takes force and all-out. The gap in saber skill between ANH and RotS isn't that significant IMO, and whatever he lacks there he makes up in force; not to mention old Ben has the mentality advantage over his younger self.