Vader vs. Grand Inquisitor

Started by |King Joker|4 pages

The Grand Inquisitor is obviously not High Council level, come on, lol.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
Why does he scale both above the 7th and 5th? What I'm going with is this, you really expect that the writers wanted the GI to be a Council level combatant? You sure?

Sidious or Vader implied he was the best of the inqusitors in the most recent comic, and he's considered their master.
Originally posted by Zenwolf
I'm not denying that the GI isn't great, but I feel adding him to Council level is a little bit of a stretch. I'm willing to place him at Knight level, because that's more sound until there's more information. 1 comic issue doesn't cut that.
[/B]

It's not just one comic issue, it's all the scaling he gets over incarnations of Kanan and other inqusitors who have feats that place them at their level.
Originally posted by Zenwolf
Unless of course, the writers don't give a flying bantha about placement in relation to where characters stand as combatants. [/B]

Why would the GI being on the level of council masters mean the writers don't give a crap about where characters stand as combatants?
Based on what can't the GI be on the level of council masters?

Originally posted by |King Joker|
The Grand Inquisitor is obviously not High Council level, come on, lol.

If all you have here is an appeal to incredulity, I'll be ignoring that in favor of the GI's scaling and feats which are more impressive than what members of the council have to offer.

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Based on what can't the GI be on the level of council masters?

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Well given he was a Knight, I'd say he by definition was Knight level.

Except he has more experience since the purge, can now tap into the dark side, and is later trained by Vader. So I'd assume he's substantially above knight level

Actually you know what? Fine if you wanna believe he's Council level, though this makes the writers complete idiots on Rebels for introducing such a supposedly powerful character for all of 1 Season and then come in with 2 lesser powerful characters for the remainder.

How in that is logical progression? You don't fight the boss first and then fight the minions. But you know, with all the face scrunching writing going on in Canon...well hey, lets just throw all sense out the window.

Since when did Rebels have logical progression?

Originally posted by Zenwolf
Actually you know what? Fine if you wanna believe he's Council level, though this makes the writers complete idiots on Rebels for introducing such a supposedly powerful character for all of 1 Season and then come in with 2 lesser powerful characters for the remainder.

How in that is logical progression? You don't fight the boss first and then fight the minions. But you know, with all the face scrunching writing going on...well hey, lets just throw all sense out the window.


Uh yea, the logical progression is from the inquisitor to Darth Vader, someone who would roflstomp most council masters.

And yes, if they wanted to bring in Darth fcking Vader, they'd throw out the inquisitor even if he was on par with Kit Fisto.

Stop trying to second guess authorial intent and just take the L zen.

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Uh yea, the logical progression is from the inquisitor to Darth Vader, someone who would roflstomp most council masters.

And yes, if they wanted to bring in Darth fcking Vader, they'd throw out the inquisitor even if he was on par with Kit Fisto.

Stop trying to second guess authorial intent and just take the L zen.

Darth Vader wasn't the antagonist in the series, he had best showed up a few times, the actual antagonists were the Inquisitors.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
Actually you know what? Fine if you wanna believe he's Council level, though this makes the writers complete idiots on Rebels for introducing such a supposedly powerful character for all of 1 Season and then come in with 2 lesser powerful characters for the remainder.

How in that is logical progression? You don't fight the boss first and then fight the minions. But you know, with all the face scrunching writing going on in Canon...well hey, lets just throw all sense out the window.

Even if the GI isn't Councilor-level that's exactly what happened.

Originally posted by ares834
Even if the GI isn't Councilor-level that's exactly what happened.

True, but now it's just worse if true.

Kanan Jarrus > Council members confirmed.

This was obvious. :/

Kanan vs Savage?
Also Syn GH

Kanan ragdolls.

Nah, doing essays.

I think you're trolling, but not sure.

Only for 10 minutes

🙂

Originally posted by Zenwolf
True, but now it's just worse if true.

If what Ares said is true regardless of how powerful the GI is, then your argument here is bunk. 👆

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
If what Ares said is true regardless of how powerful the GI is, then your argument here is bunk. 👆

My argument wasn't even that. That wasn't even really an argument.