Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Pablo puts a bunch of nonsense in those books, including Kit Fisto > Darth Maul, Plo Koon > Mother Talzin, Qui-Gon > Yoda, etc.That being said, I have a feeling the Luke in that book is ESB, not ROTJ or TFA. I might be wrong, though.
Honestly Plo Koon > Mother Talzin may not be that bad considering from their point of view Talzin's more of what the Forcecast would call a "support" role in the Force.
But yeah, I don't see Plo Koon contending with Sidious the way Talzin did lol.
Too bad her fight with Mace was mostly offscreen. Frackin Jar Jar ruined it again. Would've been nice to finally see Mace with an accurate portrayal of Vaapad since ROTS had Ian holding the fights speed back although I don't blame him.
Regardless, it would've been nice to see Mother Talzin's abilities as a swordswoman.
Originally posted by The Merchant
Head to Head says ROTJ Luke>ROTS Anakin>Vader>Yoda.
ROTJ Luke VS ROTS Anakin is one of the videos Antoine's done that I actually like.
However, ROTJ Luke being physically stronger than ROTS Anakin is nonsense and I think Anakin would take more than an 8/10 majority.
ROTS Anakin > ROTJ Vader actually makes sense.
Vader > Yoda was putting ESB-ROTJ Vader against Yoda in exile so that may make sense considering he's sorta gone mad in ESB which is probably what spending time to yourself after the order you've dedicated your life to for almost 9 centuries is destroyed. But yeah, ROTS Yoda > ROTJ Vader easily.
Lookin at you Jensaaurai.
Originally posted by DarthAnt66Well of course they are. He's a lousy filmmaker. He's not going to see quality when it's his own franchise hitting him in the face. He's biased toward the things he had the most creative control over, and those happened to be absolutely atrocious films.
Funny considering that, besides TFA, ANH and ESB are Lucas' least favorites.