bluewaterrider
Senior Member
An encore is in order here, for people may get the idea that, because I've publicly argued with Jamal before and am critiquing his work that I don't genuinely appreciate certain aspects of it.
Little could be further from the truth, and, in fact, years ago I gave it praise in a thread devoted to artists who managed to convey a sense of the "tactile" in one or more of their works.
Here's the image in question:
Here's what I liked about it:
Originally posted by bluewaterrider
Thought about what you said about anatomy, Mindship.
Think the reason the 3 that inspired this thread do so is because they are intuitive.
I'll point out what I find special about each in turn and in depth now.
3. Kara Zor-el versus Silver Banshee, Shea Stadium
This scene is remarkable for how well it captures instinctive response.
There's no sense of artificial posing. What you see from Kara is nearly exactly what you see from anyone under sudden attack from a source coming straight to the face. One arm instantly positions its hand as a shield close to the face itself, the other extends quickly outward to block or push away the attacker. Eyelids shut, chin goes down close to chest if it can. The only major departure from this classic response is that Kara holds her shielding hand against her ear, perfectly appropriate under the circumstances, a vain attempt to block the sonic nature of Banshee's assault. Banshee herself is a grasping, screeching, muscular harpy-like figure. Her flexed bicep implies her physical strength, her other hand, though, stretching the material of Supergirl's outfit as she grabs at Kara's chest, looks like the claw of some giant bird of prey.
The detail that makes this, though, is Kara's hand on Banshee's forehead, striving desperately to keep that dangerous cawing mouth from either neck or ears. It's a masterpiece in the way it captures the painful, desperate intimacy of close-quarters struggle.
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=14164287
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Source: Supergirl #34, Volume 5
Writer: Sterling Gates
Penciller: Jamal Igle
Date: December 2008
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://dc.wikia.com/wiki/Supergirl_Vol_5_34