Powerless Supes vs. Powerless Rogers

Supes as shown when Bats was training him.

Rogers in his scrawny form (NOT the peak human sans SSS form), like how he was depicted in Steve Rogers: Super Soldier mini.

Physicals or skill?

Uh, I would beat the shit out of scrawny Rogers, and Superman is like my height but built like Arnold.

He’d win 10/10 baring Rogers pulling a “David and Goliath”.

Yet Steve handled two SSS freaks with his skill 😎

Feats over rl logic.

Meanwhile, in DC:

Originally posted by cdtm
That time powerless Superman lost to fat, one handed Lex Luther.

Steve stomps Clark.

Originally posted by RealityWarper
Steve stomps Clark.

give to the street kid over the farm boy

Clark would probably beat the mess out of Steve under these stipulations. Anyone want to give it a try? Go out and pick a fight with someone much larger than yourself, just too see how easily they hurt you, and how difficult it is to hurt them. It's not impossible, but c'mon, the odds are clearly against you.

Clark ftw. 7.5/10

Overweight Luthor with a stump would beat Rogers? 😛

Originally posted by Stoic
Clark would probably beat the mess out of Steve under these stipulations. Anyone want to give it a try? Go out and pick a fight with someone much larger than yourself, just too see how easily they hurt you, and how difficult it is to hurt them. It's not impossible, but c'mon, the odds are clearly against you.

Clark ftw. 7.5/10

Steve actually beat up SSS soldiers as a scrawny dude

👆

And Clark got assraped by one-armed overweight hypertension Lex.

Yeah but he's now trained by Bats 👆

We both know he can forget everything he learned in less than 1 second.

Clark 9-10/10
He sons Rogers

I want to say a noodle armed, light in the butt Rogers could win some thru sheer tenacity but I don't see it happening.. He puts up a fight.