Palpatine is the strongest of the contenders and laughably way too fast and strong for the muslims imo. He stomps through, they get the jihad treatment. š
Most of the others can do it, but prolly in this order:
- RotS Palpatine
- RotS Anakin
- Rebels Vader / Maul / Grievous
- RotJ Luke / the trio / Bane and Zannah
Rebels Vader > Grievous, but Grievous has abilities more suited towards this slaughter. Same goes for why RotJ Luke is below them, his skillset doesn't suit slaughter like this.
The trio is on par with Bane+Zannah and Luke for similar reasons of good skillset. Tthey are much below the Force Sensitives, but from my personal IRL experience, ranged weapons have far greater success against the muslims than melee combat. Probably because of half of them never seeing a gun and having this animal instinct to go into close quarters and lack of brains to realize the gun has a greater reach. Also US Army proved in history that flamethrowers are excellent weaponry against low-tier subhumans.
*
In case of bonus:
- RotS Palpatine - wins; their numbers don't mean much when their weaponry is so severely lacking and their outmatched several leagues. Sidious can blitz people like Kolar that would blitz people that can blitz several muslims. That speed should allow him to win.
- Rebels Vader - probably loses. Too restrained mobility, and pure-Canon characters are far behind in terms of speed, and you need insanely over-the-top superhuman reflexes to push through these numbers.
- Maul - wins. Given his expertise in nearly all martial arts, endless stamina and top-of-the-mythos endurance he has severe advantage over the muslims. Most of them won't be able to phase him or hurt him, so he should be able to manage.
- RotJ Luke - loses.
- RotS Anakin - wins if he takes his speed and strength to the maximum. Also, if he realizes muslims are rapists and threat to people like Padme or his mother, he can stomp.
- Grievous - his armor can't be damaged by the muslims, it will be like trying to defeat a tank in a melee. He may need time to dispose of them, that's all.
- The trio - they lose.
- Bane and Zannah - they lose.