Originally posted by Adam_PoE
That does not make the innocent people murdered in the resulting conflict any less dead, or this strategy an effective way to achieve the stated goal.If the goal is to achieve peace, or minimally, end conflict, this strategy does neither of those. In fact, it does the exact opposite of what it purports to set out to do.
So tell me, why this is a good plan? Because "doing something different to do something different" is not a good enough justification when people are going to be killed.
You keep citing this "doing something different!" thing. That isn't why I agree. Some people might be constantly bringing that up, but not me. If I said it once it is not something I'm using a lot.
I look at the situation, I look at what Congress decided in 1995. I see presidents promised and then backed out. I see 22 years having passed.
And it comes down to Islam. We all know what it means when experts talk about violence occurring. We all know who will be behind it. And yes, these savages will kill innocent people and try to use this as an excuse.
I don't know what else to tell you. I don't want people to die, but I do not want us to let an abhorrent religion dictate the decisions we make.