Rank these incarnations of Anakin/Vader

Started by slayne2 pages
slayne Revanite

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
1. Knightfall
2. Zonakin
3. Pre-Zonakin
4. Mustafar
5. End of TCW

Vader ranges from 4 to 6.

MarrCaedusRevan Junior Member

1. Knightfall
2. Zonakin
3. RotJ
4. ESB
5. Mustafar
6. RotS “base”
7. End of TCW
8. ANH

Naugrim Restricted

1. RotJ
2/3. Zone/ESB
4/5. Knightfall/ANH
6. RotS "base"
7. End of TCW
8. Mustafar

Sirion_Of_Doom Restricted

Re: Rank these incarnations of Anakin/Vader

Originally posted by The Ellimist
A. With Legends + movies/novelizations/TCW (aka old canon)
B. With Canon

In one vs. one combat in an open field, 10 meters.

Knightfall
Zone
RotJ
RotS "base"
Mustafar
End of TCW
ANH
ESB


''zone''
rots
rotj
esb
TCW
mustafar
anh

BazookaMaster Senior Member

1. Zonakin

2. Knightfall

3. Base ROTS

4. ROTJ + ESB (slightly lower)

5. ANH

6. Mustafar

7. TCW

Rockydonovang freedom fighter

What about End of ROTJ vader? When he was brought back to the light and was walking through Sidious's lightning? Shouldn't we consider him too, as another version of Anakin?

JKBart Restricted

that's the suit that walked through the lightning tbh